Only thing i can say for sure
Cam was a better rapper when dipset came out than he was after it ended.They all were.
But Jim ended up making generally good tapes without dips. From diary of a sunmer to purple city, etc. ill take jims over cams past 15-20.
All the other stuff is whatever to me. And I think cam is a way better rapper. But jim has a good team and picks good tracks on his own and is better at it solo wise than cam is imo. Havent felt anything but a handful of cam songs since “i used to get it in ohio” / “hate my job”
In 2003/4 it was a no brainer. But today? Jim may be ahead when talking about the past 20 years.