CAC Girl In Blackface Claims "Transethnic"

[Matt504]

Threads like this and the replacement of actual thought with dogma and intellectual tail-chasing made me stop posting here. The thought leaders are thoughtless.

and yet here you are, posting.



trans-hypocrite?

 

[Consigliere]

Nothing wrong with this, this is what I want too. I don't want to be near any of these Devils. Keep them away.

Prime example of the lack of historical knowledge that passes for pro Black speech around here.

 

[Matt504]

Prime example of the lack of historical knowledge that passes for pro Black speech around here.

can you provide the historical knowledge that makes up for the lack in the person's post you quoted?

or are you just here to stir shyt?

 

[Mr Rager]

I believe if a person is born with a penis, that person is a male.



can you explain why transethnic isn't real and transgender is?

that's what I've been waiting for since I discovered this thread and no one has yet to give any meaningful answers here nor anywhere else I've looked, people are just dismissing the idea altogether, much like straight people have dismissed the idea of a person born with a penis deciding that he wants to identify as a female.

If the trolling wasn't brilliant, there'd be no discussion because the argument would immediately be shut down with reasons why transethnicity is invalid and transgender is valid, I have yet to see those reasons, but what I have seen is a ton of hypocrisy, surprisingly from transgendered people who have had their sexual identities rejected by straight people.

once again, if the points raised in this trolling are amateurish or erroneous, please explain how for all of us to see.

First I want to say that I agree this is A-1 trolling on her part. But it does offer up an interesting point that nobody is addressing.
In my opinion her post equates racial stereotyping to gender stereotyping.
A lot of "trans" men say that because they wanted to play with dolls or wear dresses and play hopscotch as children mean that they felt like they were "supposed" to be female, even though these these things are stereotypical female activities. Same with females, just because you want to play sports or other stereotypical male activities doesn't mean you were "supposed" to be male. It's not possible to "feel" like you are supposed to be something that you never were. These ideas are based on stereotypes.

Just my opinion, correct me if you think I'm off base

 

[Consigliere]

and yet here you are, posting.



trans-hypocrite?

Have some pos rep. You're doing a great job.

 

[RC-P90]

you haven't heard of it, therefore it doesn't exist...

interesting



here's that experience you're looking for.

http://blackwomenvalues.tumblr.com/blackidentity

you need more people...and some links/sources that didnt come from tumblr...

 

[Consigliere]

can you provide the historical knowledge that makes up for the lack in the person's post you quoted?

or are you just here to stir shyt?

Segregation has, recently I might add, been proven to be a poor response to white supremacy. People who propose such solutions are either:

A) historically unaware
B) naive about globalization
C) white supremacists
D) some combination of all of the above and therefore not really worthy of leading any kind of discussion about anything, let alone something as sensitive and important as race.

Then you add on that's he's quoting a racist yt bytch who paints herself in Black face, and it makes me wonder why you are in here throwing your coat over mud puddles to substantiate her brilliance.

 

[ORDER_66]

 

[Matt504]

First I want to say that I agree this is A-1 trolling on her part. But it does offer up an interesting point that nobody is addressing.
In my opinion her post equates racial stereotyping to gender stereotyping.
A lot of "trans" men say that because they wanted to play with dolls or wear dresses and play hopscotch as children mean that they felt like they were "supposed" to be female, even though these these things are stereotypical female activities. Same with females, just because you want to play sports or other stereotypical male activities doesn't mean you were "supposed" to be male. It's not possible to "feel" like you are supposed to be something that you never were. These ideas are based on stereotypes.

Just my opinion, correct me if you think I'm off base

you get it.

this is why I say the trolling is brilliant because you can't argue against transethnicity while being in favor of transgender without looking like a hypocrite. it's either all or nothing.

note the hypocrisy in this tumblr post and imagine this hate being directed at a transgendered person, it'd be completely unacceptable and condemned.

 

[Mr Rager]

you get it.

this is why I say the trolling is brilliant because you can't argue against transethnicity while being in favor of transgender without looking like a hypocrite. it's either all or nothing.

note the hypocrisy in this tumblr post and imagine this hate being directed at a transgendered person, it'd be completely unacceptable and condemned.

Unintentional self ether.

 

[King Poetic]

#TRANSTHENEWBLACK

 

[Matt504]

Segregation has, recently I might add, been proven to be a poor response to white supremacy. People who propose such solutions are either:

A) historically unaware
B) naive about globalization
C) white supremacists
D) some combination of all of the above and therefore not really worthy of leading any kind of discussion about anything, let alone something as sensitive and important as race.

Then you add on that's he's quoting a racist yt bytch who paints herself in Black face, and it makes me wonder why you are in here throwing your coat over mud puddles to substantiate her brilliance.

segregation was never a response to white supremacy, the power to keep people segregated lied solely in the hands of white people, and they did everything in their power to keep Black people away from them while Civil Rights activists fought to integrate. The Black people who were advocating for segregation wanted a separate but equal society, for more information refer to this speech by Malcolm X when he was advocating for complete separation from white people.



I'm not throwing my coat over any mud puddles whatsoever, but simply acknowledging that this is a remarkable example of trolling. it's possible to see a woman walking towards a puddle of mud and compliment how nice her shoes are never bothering to lay down my coat.

 

[Raava]

I do actually. I get what she's trying to do, I just don't like the way she went about it, I also don't want to instill a social champion title on her because it could have been done in other ways. I say that because what of this is the nee wave where people combat the whole transsexual movement by using blackface as a talking point.

Nobody installing social champion on her, caping, saying she is right or anything. This not even to be taken that way. It's just what she said, what she did and the reactions are crazy because of how hypocritical they are.

You guys are acting like if a poster didn't Just say FDB, it's co-signing or excusing her racism against blacks, it's not.

 

[Consigliere]

segregation was never a response to white supremacy, the power to keep people segregated lied solely in the hands of white people, and they did everything in their power to keep Black people away from them while Civil Rights activists fought to integrate. The Black people who were advocating for segregation wanted a separate but equal society, for more information refer to this speech by Malcolm X when he was advocating for complete separation from white people.



I'm not throwing my coat over any mud puddles whatsoever, but simply acknowledging that this is a remarkable example of trolling. it's possible to see a woman walking towards a puddle of mud and compliment how nice her shoes are never bothering to lay down my coat.

Segregation can't be a solution. Take it off the table and spend your intellectual energy on an idea that doesn't give aid and comfort to the enemy. There is no running from White Supremacy in the modern world unless you're dreaming of separate planets.

I know it wasn't a response. It was a misguided proposed response. And in general, self-segregation is a cowardly way to face the world. Can't win if you aren't in the arena. And there's no evidence we were winning while being forcefully segregated.

My main gripe here is that you should be caping for your people first and foremost instead of some random chick. Can't ever condone a yt bytch wearing blackface even if it's "for a good cause." Or whatever people are trying to argue in here. The hate agenda should always take a backseat to the protect the image of my brothers and sisters agenda.

 

[sun raw]

brilliant trolling my ass, this is lame as hack there's no originality anymore damn