I think Unified and GBH night 2 (vs KENTA) are his highest rated matches by Meltz.
One of the funniest ratings is the Morishima classic at Manhattan Mayhem that was voted match of the year and Dave went like ****1/2
I think that was the nail in the coffin for me taking seriously anything WON related for match quality.
Cagematch has a more comprehensive ratings archive (at least in the sense of having them all in one place) plus they also add the WON's rating.
Now, Cagematch is Rotten Tomatoes to Meltzer's Roger Ebert. But regardless, none should be taken as gospel or as anything more than people having their own taste in what's good or not.