Brady-Manning is probably the greatest rivalry in the history of American Sports.

[Juggalo Fred]

Yankees vs red Sox?
I don't even like baseball.

Yankees vs red sawx is too one sided

I mean 27 titles vs 7 titles...not even close

 

[Black White Sox Hat]

Over Wilt/Russell?

 

[KOBE]

So what do you all think about Peyton vs. Bill then? Aka the real rivalry.

 

[QuavoFlow]

giants and pats>>>>>>brady vs manning

 

[mastermind]

McEnroe/Borg

Federer/Nadal

Bonds/Baseball media

 

[Captain Crunch]

McEnroe/Borg

Federer/Nadal

Bonds/Baseball media

 

[onelastdeath]

Federer/Nadal

Fair, but Fed/Rafa has spread across many countries and is not just American

And neither one is American

 

[premier58]

So what do you all think about Peyton vs. Bill then? Aka the real rivalry.

Peyton has owned BB since 05. That little defensive mastermind kryptonite, has long been over.

 

[TKOK]

Can' be the top when they aren't ever on the field together. Magic vs Bird and Wilt vs Russell are on top if going strictly player vs player.

 

[Dank Hill]

 

[Rocket Scientist]

Kobe-Snaq

 

[PhonZhi]

OP is correct. It is one of the more riveting rivalries in sports history. When they play against each other we all pay attention. Its a special event. Im not agreeing with OP in sayint its at the top or even near the top, but its a legit rivalry that im sure everyone that has posted in this thread has been interested in at some point.