loyola llothta
☭☭☭
“(T)ERRO" (the first documentary to place filmmakers on the ground during an active FBI counterterrorism sting operation, as seen through the perspective of “Shariff,” a 63-year-old Black revolutionary turned informant) ON Netflix JUNE 30th
The premise of (T)ERROR is astounding. Documentary directors Lyric R Cabral and David Felix Sutcliffe gained access to both an undercover FBI informant, Saeed, who was working on a counterterrorism operation, and Khalifah, the target that the FBI instructed him to investigate. Neither knew that the crew was filming both sides as it was playing out. The FBI’s system of counterterrorism informants is inherently broken, as the directors describe, but it’s hard to get the message out with a film this flawed.
Cabral and Sutcliffe spent seven months in Pittsburgh tracking Saeed, an African-American Muslim, and his prey, an American who was raised Protestant but converted to militant Islam. The first hour of the film is spent looking at Saeed’s life as an FBI informant and the cases he’s worked in the past. The narrative doesn’t pick up steam until that hour is concluded, when the FBI interferes in Saeed’s infiltration. They force Saeed to introduce an agent to Khalifah, who immediately unmasks him just by Googling his cellphone number. After months of getting to know Khalifah, Saeed’s cover is blown.
This is riveting stuff, but the boring setup, which wastes too much time on the minutiae of Saeed’s investigation, is enough to scare many people away from the action-packed final 30 minutes. The film-makers’ inexperience shows (this is the first feature for Cabral and second for Sutcliffe) and they seem unsure how to whittle down the footage of Saeed early in his investigation.
This is a very important topic. The evidence presented makes it look like the FBI is entrapping American Muslims into crimes using highly paid informants. By the end of (T)ERROR, we see both Saeed and Khalifah as victims, desperate men played against each other by a government striving to make more terrorism arrests, even as their tactics drive more people to terrorism. This information needs to be shown to the public, and some will be drawn to it regardless of its form. But as a well-crafted film, it has a long way to go.