Bird or Durant

Greater player All-Time?


  • Total voters
    111
  • Poll closed .

Erratic415

Superstar
Joined
Feb 20, 2017
Messages
5,687
Reputation
1,872
Daps
16,427
This isn't completely fair to KD.

Now, look, he did play on some formidable teams with great talent, but he was extremely unfortunate with the way his tenure in OKC played out:

- Made a Finals run in 2012 (aged 23), but ran into arguably the greatest player of all-time, at his peak
- Lost in the second round in 2013 because Westbrook was injured and had to rely on K-Mart and Reggie as his running mates
- Lost in the WCF in 2014 to the NBA Champion Spurs (one could argue this was one of their best iterations)
- Injured in 2015
- Lost in the WCF in 2016 to a 73-win Warriors squad, who needed superhuman efforts from Steph and Klay (I still maintain if OKC had won that series they would've won the championship).

Essentially, his playoff career in OKC comprised of coming up against some the greatest teams of the modern era. That's all that really stood between him and a championship, shyt, even multiple championships.

Bird isn't beating the 2012 Heat, or the 2014 Spurs or the 2016 Warriors. Bird didn't beat one team during his Championship runs that was on the same level as any of those three teams. He had multiple hiccups against worse competition during his career too.

Bird would definitely catch a lot of flack in today’s era for shooting struggles in postseason losses, and Boston’s many times being eliminated with Home Court Advantage.

I don’t know how I’m comparing him with KD though. I find these different generation comparisons pretty hard.
 

Cladyclad

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 3, 2012
Messages
44,211
Reputation
4,609
Daps
113,097
Reppin
Detroit Lions, Michigan Wolverines & LWO
This ain’t Hot Tub Time Machine tho

u right. it’s Hot Tub Time Machine Part 2 motherfukker

Bird thought Penny and C Webb were unicorns

just imagine him lining up against a 7 footer that is
bigger
taller
faster
better defender
better handle

that French hick gon be :mindblown:
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jan 19, 2017
Messages
34,606
Reputation
-678
Daps
84,651
u right it’s Hot Tub Time Machine Part 2 motherfukker

Bird thought Penny and C Webb were unicorns

just imagine him lining up against a 7 footer that is
bigger
taller
faster
better defender
better handle

that French hick gon be :mindblown:

Can’t expect Mortal Kombat 1 before Mortal Kombat 1 :banderas:
 

premier58

All Star
Joined
Apr 10, 2015
Messages
5,523
Reputation
268
Daps
10,752
u right. it’s Hot Tub Time Machine Part 2 motherfukker

Bird thought Penny and C Webb were unicorns

just imagine him lining up against a 7 footer that is
bigger
taller
faster
better defender
better handle

that French hick gon be :mindblown:
Faster? Durant is nowhere as athletic as Penny or Webber. Pennys handle is wayy better than Durant. Webber is bigger than KD.
 

ISO

Pass me the rock nikka
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
61,107
Reputation
8,207
Daps
194,748
Reppin
BX, NYC
Spooky this cac was advertised as one of the clutchest killers of All-Time

Going off the lore and old head romanticization you start to believe shyt
 
Top