Better overall Career Brees or P.Manning ?

[KiD WavE]

So I am watching NFL AM on NFL network and they ask this question and this freckle faced fakkit tries to say Brees. I dont even know why it was a question in the first place besides denver vs saints this week.


so am I crazy or should dude be fired on the spot

 

[Street Knowledge]

Manning is a top 5 QB of all time and Brees is 12-15

 

[Brozay]

Clearly Manning

 

[Trip]

Brees New Orleans vs Manning Indy is close.

If were factoring in Brees in SD, its clearly Manning

 

[MAKAVELI25]

Manning is a top 5 QB of all time and Brees is 12-15

Exactly, it's not even debatable. Only QB from the current era that can be compared to Manning is Brady, and that's despite the fact that A-Rod is currently the best in the league. A few more years of consistency and both A-Rod and Drew might be on that level, Peyton Manning has been on his Surgeon shyt for years

 

[BrohanSolo]

If were factoring in Brees in SD, its clearly Manning

 

[Urahara_Kisuke]

Peyton Williams Manning

 

[Stone]

this reminds me of what happened to Brady when he went down a couple years back. People just lost all sense of perspective.

 

[cfountain]

Even as a Saints fan its Manning.

But I'm glad we have Drew

 

[mvp_status]

Brees New Orleans vs Manning Indy is close.

Manning had 4 MVP trophies in Indy to Brees 0

 

[Spliff]

kinda question is this

 

[SmoothOperator88]

Manning is considered by some to be the GOAT while the Chargers threw Brees in the bushes in the early stages of his prime. This isn't debatable for even a millisecond.

Manning >>>> Brees

 

[OneManGang]

Am i the only one who thinks this is closer than some of the previous posters are making it out to be? Peyton the Gawd and all but Drew has carved out a nice lil career so far as well....i've always said too that Peyton folded under pressure in the playoffs. 1 Super bowl with the career he has had and the teams he has had isn't good enough even when you take Brees out the equation.

 

[NOSaintsFan02]

Manning had 4 MVP trophies in Indy to Brees 0

Drew should have won in 2009, but he just took the Super Bowl MVP from Manning instead. I'll take it.

 

[Stone]

Am i the only one who thinks this is closer than some of the previous posters are making it out to be? Peyton the Gawd and all but Drew has carved out a nice lil career so far as well....i've always said too that Peyton folded under pressure in the playoffs. 1 Super bowl with the career he has had and the teams he has had isn't good enough even when you take Brees out the equation.

his stats in the playoffs are as good as anybody's who has played the amount of games he's played though.