Best Wrestler Alive Tourney 2nd Round --- Shawn Michaels vs. Scott Hall
- Thread starter 2CT
- Start date
Image? Bryan doesnt do fake injuries to forfeit titles in his prime..Michaels doesnt have one match better than Danielson vs McGuiness title vs title match.
Close the voting now, it's just going to embarrass Hall
Tres Leches
Empire Business
Scott hall Easy choice for me 
Wait this is round two
You really forgot to add Dreamer
You left me no choice
If I can figure out how to create a poll, your little tournament might be in trouble
Have a good day @2 Cold Taurus
breh who on the bracket could Dreamer beat? even Orange Cassidy would've washed him
Cartier Murphy
Apathy’s a Tragedy & Boredom is a Crime
Going for Razor for the fukkery
breh who on the bracket could Dreamer beat? even Orange Cassidy would've washed him
Dreamer would've washed Gargano & Ted Dibiase
Last edited:
Bryan Danielson
Jmare007 x Bryan Danielson x JLova = King Ghidorah
breh who on the bracket could Dreamer beat? even Orange Cassidy would've washed him
You fukked up...... should’ve had Dreamer vs Joey Ryan
OmegaK2099
Gettin' It In
I voted Hall
Bryan Danielson
Jmare007 x Bryan Danielson x JLova = King Ghidorah
Change y’all votes to Hall
Hall is my goat 
Edit: behind macho
Edit: behind macho
The Entity
Pro
If you account for a wrestlers full capabilities, I don't see how objectively you get HBK over Scott Hall
Mic:
Revisionist history has been really good to HBK. Even at his best, he was never great on the mic. He would say shock value smark shyt that wasn't really creative and when he wasn't doing a poor man's nwo schtick, he lost his smile. DX was the generic version of the NWO, because HBK and HHH were the generic versions of hall and nash. He wasn't as naturally cool nor nearly as gifted on the mic. Every HBK promo sounded the same, he's talking factually and grating his voice hoping you believe him. "Hey, its me, H-B-K...I was raised in San Antonio...and tonight, in front of this sold out arena, we are going to wrestle. I don't know if i am going to win *points at self* I don't know if your going to win *points at opponent*...but one thing is for sure, there will be a winner." Conversely, Scott Hall could do serious promos (as a babyface) heat/troll promos (All of his NWO work), chicken shyt heel (zbysco) character promos (Razor) in GOAT tier. Scott hall got a has been larry zbysco over before they even even wrestled. Shawn Michaels couldn't get corona relief checks over in a promo.
'Rasslin:
Sure, many regard HBK as a great and perhaps GOAT in-ring wrestler of all time, but scott hall was in the next tier below him. Let's not forget Scott hall could believably work with any size because he was versatile and could use his height in a way that benefited the match and opponent. Shawn Michaels had to bump around for his opponents and legitimately cry, Scott didnt have to resort to such bush-league antics.
Other considerations:
Scott Hall personified charisma, Shawn Michaels was a cock-eyed whiney fukk boy. Scott Hall was an instrumental part of the most legendary and revolutionary angle off all time. The best era of wrestling, and WWE, happened when Shawn Michaels finally got out the way. Scott hall gave us the goat version of Sting, HBK gave us ...Lance Cade. Razor's edge >> stupid kick. Scott Hall never resorted to using God to get over, Shawn Michaels did (and STILL lost in a tag match to 2 non-wrestlers). Essentially, youd have to believe that HBK was so much better at wrestling to compensate for his other gaping deficiencies to Hall or you'd have to value wrestling several times over anything else.
Mic:
Revisionist history has been really good to HBK. Even at his best, he was never great on the mic. He would say shock value smark shyt that wasn't really creative and when he wasn't doing a poor man's nwo schtick, he lost his smile. DX was the generic version of the NWO, because HBK and HHH were the generic versions of hall and nash. He wasn't as naturally cool nor nearly as gifted on the mic. Every HBK promo sounded the same, he's talking factually and grating his voice hoping you believe him. "Hey, its me, H-B-K...I was raised in San Antonio...and tonight, in front of this sold out arena, we are going to wrestle. I don't know if i am going to win *points at self* I don't know if your going to win *points at opponent*...but one thing is for sure, there will be a winner." Conversely, Scott Hall could do serious promos (as a babyface) heat/troll promos (All of his NWO work), chicken shyt heel (zbysco) character promos (Razor) in GOAT tier. Scott hall got a has been larry zbysco over before they even even wrestled. Shawn Michaels couldn't get corona relief checks over in a promo.
'Rasslin:
Sure, many regard HBK as a great and perhaps GOAT in-ring wrestler of all time, but scott hall was in the next tier below him. Let's not forget Scott hall could believably work with any size because he was versatile and could use his height in a way that benefited the match and opponent. Shawn Michaels had to bump around for his opponents and legitimately cry, Scott didnt have to resort to such bush-league antics.
Other considerations:
Scott Hall personified charisma, Shawn Michaels was a cock-eyed whiney fukk boy. Scott Hall was an instrumental part of the most legendary and revolutionary angle off all time. The best era of wrestling, and WWE, happened when Shawn Michaels finally got out the way. Scott hall gave us the goat version of Sting, HBK gave us ...Lance Cade. Razor's edge >> stupid kick. Scott Hall never resorted to using God to get over, Shawn Michaels did (and STILL lost in a tag match to 2 non-wrestlers). Essentially, youd have to believe that HBK was so much better at wrestling to compensate for his other gaping deficiencies to Hall or you'd have to value wrestling several times over anything else.
More importantly, Hall had a bigger impact in 96 than Shawn Michaels had his entire career.