Best Spider-Man Actor By Far

[Peter Popoff]

Tobi was a great Peter terrible Spider-Man honestly no quips, no Spidey personality whatsoever (even though 2 is still the GOAT Spider-Man movie well live action at least because Spiderverse might have the crown)

Garfield was the perfect Spider-Man but a Peter

Tom has been great as both not a better Peter than Tobi or a better Spidey than Garfield but he’s the perfect balance of both.

Alfred Molina, a highly underrated actor made spiderman 2 the GOAT as Doc Ock but Tom Holland embodies Peter Parker as a youngin to the T.

 

[SunZoo]

Andrew was perfect in the suit, but he was too cool as Peter.

Holland channeling Michael J Fox for his version was a brilliant way to approach the role.

 

[dakidbanks]

PS4 Spider-Man is the best

Which reminded me of TAS Spidey... but Tom is the best live action

 

[OmegaK2099]

Garfield

 

[the cool]

how was garfield a good spider man in suit?

 

[parallax]

coming off of mcguire spider man, he was a breath of fresh air.

 

[Luke Cage]

Andrew was perfect in the suit, but he was too cool as Peter.

Holland channeling Michael J Fox for his version was a brilliant way to approach the role.

Crazy part is i always thought Michael J Fox would've been the perfect casting for spiderman when i was little.

 

[Take It In Blood]

you'll see him again when Sony drops the live action into the spiderverse with Tom Holland, Tobey and this breh

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

Toby was wack

Garfield was a douche

Holland handles the marvel touch really well. But I think he's a puss. Doesn't come off as a hero.

 

[Real]

My power rankings

Andrew
Tom
Old ass Tobey

 

[Blankthawtz]

coming off of mcguire spider man, he was a breath of fresh air.

 

[Panther]

Tom Holland is better than both of them

 

[Rekkapryde]

Andrew was perfect in the suit, but he was too cool as Peter.

Holland channeling Michael J Fox for his version was a brilliant way to approach the role.

Garfield was the best to me, but I can see the argument of him being too cool and having TOO MUCH swag as Peter.

 

[darryl]

Best Peter- tobey
Best spiderman- andrew
Best overall - Holland

I understand y'all saying that tobey was a bad Spiderman because he had no quips and personality. I agree to an extent. But I think that was more on raimi. If you played the Spiderman movie games at the time, tobey voices spiderman in all 3, he has more quips and personality in that than the movies

 

[dakidbanks]

Garfield wasn’t a good Peter but he had some dope moments in costume but the stories in his films were trash

Tom is a great balance

Tobey was a dork but his first 2 outings were piff