Notorious 1 E.Y.E.
Superstar
prisoner of azkaban
Best Harry Potter Movie?
- Thread starter Beerus
- Start date
Great opening with the caretaker getting killed, the Quidich world cup sequence was thrilling, the dragon part of the tournament and the water task was brilliant, the whole romantic subplot had me on the edge of my seat, and that final 20-30 minutes, so, so good
Bet you think Dealthy Hallows Part 1 is better
It is. It has a point. Goblet of fire is purely a transition movie from a thematic standpoint and directorial. The big deal in it is someone dies. That's it.
Wait, you didn't think Voldemort returning to his full physical form was a big deal at all?
You're right my bad. Two big things. But the movie is boring as hell for the most part and doesn't really seem to go anywhere or do anything. Voldemort comes back and someone dies. Other than that, it's a placeholder movie, especially because the person who dies ends up not mattering at all to the overall story and he's barely developed in the movie he dies in to feel anything for him
Prisoner of Azkaban was the best simply because it was the only one that really captured the energy of the HP world; the fun and the quirky charm. From characterization to set design, it's the only film to really get it
In comparison, Yates' films feel sterile. Not necessarily bad movies, but they don't have Prisoner's soul.
But Goblet of Fire was probably my favorite to watch in theater just because there was so much happening and so much action. But it was definitely a bit bombastic, and the lack of subtlety hurt it on later viewing. But it's still my second favorite overall
In comparison, Yates' films feel sterile. Not necessarily bad movies, but they don't have Prisoner's soul.
But Goblet of Fire was probably my favorite to watch in theater just because there was so much happening and so much action. But it was definitely a bit bombastic, and the lack of subtlety hurt it on later viewing. But it's still my second favorite overall
Neil Tyson
YYZ
I Like Azkaban. First time I felt the movies did the books justice.
I still believe the first two movies do those two books justice. Possibly too much tho. They're a straight translation of the book and maybe they're too literal for my taste but they're true to the books. As the books changed the direction changed which makes sense.
Must be harry potter weekend.
I like Goblet of Fire and Deathly Hallows.
I like Goblet of Fire and Deathly Hallows.
GoF was dope..only thing that irked me was Dumbledoe getting aggressive in that one scene after it's revealed Harry's name was in the goblet