It’s too small in scale and lacked the depth required for a remake.
It was cool at the time, but now it doesn’t really hold up much. It was executed just well enough at the time. But the game itself was still unfinished, clunky, and repetitive.
Story was also all over the place, I could tell they cut a lot out. And the continuity of the ending was ruined by future releases.
Many systems in the game were either barebones or not fully hashed out. From the crafting to the sea ship side economy thing.
I just played the game and DLC a few months ago.
They won’t add anything new, just give it “modern” graphics, so it’s completely unnecessary.