As hiphop fans how do we argue against this anti hiphop stance?

Still Benefited

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
40,282
Reputation
8,680
Daps
100,648
If they blackgive em the :umad: if they white give em the :childplease:....if u gotta explain its not for them....its music its simply a soundtrack for lifestyles people are already livin....I'm still waitin on sumthin to show crime rates have risen with the popularity of gangsta rap....or that that nikkas became more gangsta....communitys make rap music not the other way around.
 

CrimsonTider

Seduce & Scheme
WOAT
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
83,097
Reputation
-13,917
Daps
131,469
The guy was black and he wasn't talk about the effects of hiphop have on society

He was saying for example Nas is selling a CD full of gangsta shyt, yet he's in London partying his ass off

Jay is pushing Beyonce on the swing, yet having lyrics like "I whip the coke/ let the lawyer beat the case"

They make millions gloryfing a lifestyle that they would never go back too
 

theworldismine13

God Emperor of SOHH
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
22,708
Reputation
555
Daps
22,613
Reppin
Arrakis
The guy was black and he wasn't talk about the effects of hiphop have on society

He was saying for example Nas is selling a CD full of gangsta shyt, yet he's in London partying his ass off

Jay is pushing Beyonce on the swing, yet having lyrics like "I whip the coke/ let the lawyer beat the case"

They make millions gloryfing a lifestyle that they would never go back too

again there is nothing to rebut because its true

im a hard core hip hop head for those asking why i post here, but once i realized rap music and rappers are full of shyt and they are misguiding black culture i stopped fuking with it

another good example of how degenerate jay-z is is the whole "nikkas in paris" song, when you really think about it that song is saying what the highest potential level a rapper can ever come to, its basically a ****** in paris entertaining white people and using the worst part of black culture to make money, thats all rap is and can be, and that's fine for jay-z, but we as a race shoudlnt be aspiring to be a nikka in paris, thats just degenerate

what kills me about it is then seeing jayz do shyt like this http://www.ballerstatus.com/2012/08...-frank-ocean-gwyneth-paltrows-summer-playlist using her to push chief keef and also nas saying she is real nikka and kanye acting like a shy 7th grader on the kardashians show, i cant respect these dudes as far as them leading rap culture, there are leading rap to a place that is not in the interest of the black race

with that said, i still appreciate the art and i think most rappers mean well, but overall rap music has become a degenerate art form and detrimental to the black race, its time to move on to the next sh*t that is more positive and uplifting
 

feelosofer

#ninergang
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
48,585
Reputation
7,178
Daps
136,461
Reppin
Brick City, NJ
I would completely agree with what the guy is saying because he is right. But I would also correct him and make him realize that his myopic view on the genre is just that. The examples he is citing are the worst that hip-hop has to offer. I would compare it to me saying that heavy metal is made up of devil worshippers and neo-nazi's, are there people like that in metal, but there are different types in rock as well, just as they are in any genre of music. I would then refer them to other songs by the artists he mentioned as well as Public Enemy, Rakim, NWA, and some more modern examples like Jay Electronica, Lupe Fiasco and Kendrick Lamar.

I would also contend that while hip-hop can be negative, it is more so a reflection of the social ills in our community than a root cause though I will concede to it's rising influence due to it's current stature in pop culture.

Not a perfect argument but I that would be my rebuttal.
 

theworldismine13

God Emperor of SOHH
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
22,708
Reputation
555
Daps
22,613
Reppin
Arrakis
I would completely agree with what the guy is saying because he is right. But I would also correct him and make him realize that his myopic view on the genre is just that. The examples he is citing are the worst that hip-hop has to offer. I would compare it to me saying that heavy metal is made up of devil worshippers and neo-nazi's, are there people like that in metal, but there are different types in rock as well, just as they are in any genre of music. I would then refer them to other songs by the artists he mentioned as well as Public Enemy, Rakim, NWA, and some more modern examples like Jay Electronica, Lupe Fiasco and Kendrick Lamar.

I would also contend that while hip-hop can be negative, it is more so a reflection of the social ills in our community than a root cause though I will concede to it's rising influence due to it's current stature in pop culture.

Not a perfect argument but I that would be my rebuttal.

public enemy and rakim are good examples but NWA was the start of downfall of rap musicc

and i wouldnt even put those modern examples rappers as a saving grace, even those rappers who are supposedly intelectual, most of their songs devolve into a form of fuk/nikka/bytch/shyt wordplay within a minute
 

feelosofer

#ninergang
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
48,585
Reputation
7,178
Daps
136,461
Reppin
Brick City, NJ
public enemy and rakim are good examples but NWA was the start of downfall of rap musicc

and i wouldnt even put those modern examples rappers as a saving grace, even those rappers who are supposedly intelectual, most of their songs devolve into a form of fuk/nikka/bytch/shyt wordplay within a minute

I agree with you but in Straight out of Compton the Message is pure. Also if a critic can't see past the curse words and interpret the underlying message then I can't take their opinion serious.
 

theworldismine13

God Emperor of SOHH
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
22,708
Reputation
555
Daps
22,613
Reppin
Arrakis
I agree with you but in Straight out of Compton the Message is pure. Also if a critic can't see past the curse words and interpret the underlying message then I can't take their opinion serious.

why would i need to look past the curse words? the use of curse words is deliberate, how can you critique an art and ignore what the artist is doing? how are curse words NOT part of the "underlying" message? i use quotes because i dont actually think there is any underlying message

the idea that you can or should separate lyrics and words from the overall message or underlying message is what the problem is

im not even saying rappers are bad people, i think 90 percent of rappers are good people, but this notion that you can make a song full of curse words and also be a positive influence is a lie that was spread by the record industry, by rappers believing this lie they and the consumers too rationalize saying some of the dumbest most anti social things on record to sell records and then deluding themselves that there is nothing wrong, thats exactly what jay-z does, he is delusional
 

feelosofer

#ninergang
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
48,585
Reputation
7,178
Daps
136,461
Reppin
Brick City, NJ
why would i need to look past the curse words? the use of curse words is deliberate, how can you critique an art and ignore what the artist is doing? how are curse words NOT part of the "underlying" message? i use quotes because i dont actually think there is any underlying message

the idea that you can or should separate lyrics and words from the overall message or underlying message is what the problem is

im not even saying rappers are bad people, i think 90 percent of rappers are good people, but this notion that you can make a song full of curse words and also be a positive influence is a lie that was spread by the record industry, by rappers believing this lie they and the consumers too rationalize saying some of the dumbest most anti social things on record to sell records and then deluding themselves that there is nothing wrong, thats exactly what jay-z does, he is delusional

why would i need to look past the curse words? the use of curse words is deliberate, how can you critique an art and ignore what the artist is doing? how are curse words NOT part of the "underlying" message? i use quotes because i dont actually think there is any underlying message

the idea that you can or should separate lyrics and words from the overall message or underlying message is what the problem is

im not even saying rappers are bad people, i think 90 percent of rappers are good people, but this notion that you can make a song full of curse words and also be a positive influence is a lie that was spread by the record industry, by rappers believing this lie they and the consumers too rationalize saying some of the dumbest most anti social things on record to sell records and then deluding themselves that there is nothing wrong, thats exactly what jay-z does, he is delusional

Theres positive influence even if you curse, but beyond all that, music and media should not have this much influence, we as adults can tell the difference and we as parent need to teach children the difference between positive and negative. The cursing is as deliberate but I'm not going to invalidate what someone says based on that. The Bible/Quran/Torah are full of stories about rape, murder, oppression but am I to take away only these things, no, there are lessons to learn from these things from reading between the lines and that's what music is.

Few things are absolute, and that is the case in music or anything. A lot of the old gangsta rap talked about riots drugs and killing but if that's all you took from it, then you really weren't listening.
 

theworldismine13

God Emperor of SOHH
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
22,708
Reputation
555
Daps
22,613
Reppin
Arrakis
Theres positive influence even if you curse, but beyond all that, music and media should not have this much influence, we as adults can tell the difference and we as parent need to teach children the difference between positive and negative. The cursing is as deliberate but I'm not going to invalidate what someone says based on that. The Bible/Quran/Torah are full of stories about rape, murder, oppression but am I to take away only these things, no, there are lessons to learn from these things from reading between the lines and that's what music is.

Few things are absolute, and that is the case in music or anything. A lot of the old gangsta rap talked about riots drugs and killing but if that's all you took from it, then you really weren't listening.

well the thing is there has been a breakdown in the black family structure, so actually you are wrong, there are a lot of young people that cant extract the positive like some new york times music critic

which is exactly why i say jay-z and other rappers are delusional, i think its delusional to think that kids in the hood are seeing past the cursing and crime glorification, they arent

but anyways, its absurd to say that you should look past the cursing when cursing has, thanks to the record industry, become a fundamental part of a rap song

think about it, when was the last time you heard a rap song that didnt curse? nowadays rappers do no know how to make a rap song without cursing, my point isnt that rappers shouldn't curse, my point is that cursing limits the universe of what subject matter of rap music, so you cant ignore cursing in critiquing rap music, because cursing is fundamental to rap
 

feelosofer

#ninergang
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
48,585
Reputation
7,178
Daps
136,461
Reppin
Brick City, NJ
well the thing is there has been a breakdown in the black family structure, so actually you are wrong, there are a lot of young people that cant extract the positive like some new york times music critic

which is exactly why i say jay-z and other rappers are delusional, i think its delusional to think that kids in the hood are seeing past the cursing and crime glorification, they arent

but anyways, its absurd to say that you should look past the cursing when cursing has, thanks to the record industry, become a fundamental part of a rap song

think about it, when was the last time you heard a rap song that didnt curse? nowadays rappers do no know how to make a rap song without cursing, my point isnt that rappers shouldn't curse, my point is that cursing limits the universe of what subject matter of rap music, so you cant ignore cursing in critiquing rap music, because cursing is fundamental to rap

The black family structure breaking down pre-dates hip-hop, a lot of women will be uncomfortable hearing this this but the feminist movement played a bigger part in combination with the evolution of the welfare state, post Nixon era. Hip-Hop had nothing to do with it, even with all that there are too many factors at work for there to be a direct correlation between hip-hop and the destruction of the family structure.

I wouldn't say cursing is fundamental to hip-hop, I'll admit that is generally speaks to a lack of formal education and and an inability to express themselves otherwise as a result of the degradation of the educational system. Furthermore the point of cursing is to convey the message in an everyday parlance, that was spoken in the streets. This was a necessary evolution for expression and we needed an artform that really tested the boundaries of free speech. Yes record companies have taken advantage of that and made it an unspoken prerequisite, but I blame us as fans for having let the INDUSTRY as an entity have so much control.

Of course I can't ask children to look past the cursing, but I was under the assumption that I was talking to an adult, and yes, it is completely reasonable to ask an adult that has a cursory understanding of music to look past the profanity the same way he does reading a book or watching a movie and if he is unable to do that, then I cannot, in turn, respect his opinion for or against the artform.
 

John Hull

You can’t see me!
Joined
Jun 6, 2012
Messages
4,552
Reputation
760
Daps
14,259
Reppin
Studio gangstas
If rappers followed the basic framework of Hip Hop when NWA came out there wouldn't be the epidemic of wack gangsta rap that followed it.

In other words, Stop Biting.

They had their lane but too many cats ran with it, and that fukked shyt up for a long time. :manny:
 

OnlyInCalifornia

Southern California/Vegas
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
19,938
Reputation
3,710
Daps
52,081
Reppin
The Coli's 420th member
This entire country is based off selling dreams to people in order to get them to work hard so a small select group can benefit from it.

The American Dream is bullshyt that has been sold for years. Why peg rappers for doing it when all types of businesses have been selling 'image' and bs to poor people.
 

theworldismine13

God Emperor of SOHH
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
22,708
Reputation
555
Daps
22,613
Reppin
Arrakis
The black family structure breaking down pre-dates hip-hop, a lot of women will be uncomfortable hearing this this but the feminist movement played a bigger part in combination with the evolution of the welfare state, post Nixon era. Hip-Hop had nothing to do with it, even with all that there are too many factors at work for there to be a direct correlation between hip-hop and the destruction of the family structure.

i never said it was because of hip hop, i simply stated that it has and therefore assuming that a young mind will separate out fiction is unrealistic especially with black youth and rap music, because while other ethnic groups might listen to rap as entertainment, for a lot of black youth rap is an identity

I wouldn't say cursing is fundamental to hip-hop, I'll admit that is generally speaks to a lack of formal education and and an inability to express themselves otherwise as a result of the degradation of the educational system. Furthermore the point of cursing is to convey the message in an everyday parlance, that was spoken in the streets. This was a necessary evolution for expression and we needed an artform that really tested the boundaries of free speech. Yes record companies have taken advantage of that and made it an unspoken prerequisite, but I blame us as fans for having let the INDUSTRY as an entity have so much control.

i blame jay-z and russel simmons et al, their interests and the interests of the black community are different

Of course I can't ask children to look past the cursing, but I was under the assumption that I was talking to an adult, and yes, it is completely reasonable to ask an adult that has a cursory understanding of music to look past the profanity the same way he does reading a book or watching a movie and if he is unable to do that, then I cannot, in turn, respect his opinion for or against the artform.

i was talking about the youth and the impact rap music has, and the person the threadstarter was presumably talking about was referring to the youth

but either way i dont see why i have to look past the cursing whether in rap or a hollywood movie, why is it important to lower standards?

the problem is not the cursing in and of itself, its the fact that cursing has become the definition of a rap song, and even in hollywood movies excessive cursing and violence does take away from the art and you will lose respect and you will be restricted in your audience and subject matter, why would it be any different from rap?

and again by itself there is nothing really wrong if rap music has a lot of cursing and limited subject matter, the crux of the problem is when rap music is or becomes a form of identity for black youth, that is where the problem is and why black people should spurn rap music IMO, because then the limits of rap music become the limits of black culture.

right now the limits of rap music is being a "nikka in paris" there is nothing that a rapper can do that can go beyond being a "nikka in paris" except being a "nikka in london" http://cdn1.elitedaily.com/elite/wp...izz-beatz-kobe-bryant-carmelo-anthony-nas.jpg

why would the black community limit itself to being "nikkas in paris/london"

so basically rap music is not really in black people's interest, if the rap industry died it would be a good thing for the black community

i thank the rap industry for some good times, but overall we as black people need to move on to the next thing

and if you look around you can see the art of rap is dying, like darth vader told luke skywalker, if you look into your heart you can see the truth, rap is dying
 

frush11

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
21,168
Reputation
2,867
Daps
47,818
Reppin
NULL
again there is nothing to rebut because its true

im a hard core hip hop head for those asking why i post here, but once i realized rap music and rappers are full of shyt and they are misguiding black culture i stopped fuking with it

another good example of how degenerate jay-z is is the whole "nikkas in paris" song, when you really think about it that song is saying what the highest potential level a rapper can ever come to, its basically a ****** in paris entertaining white people and using the worst part of black culture to make money, thats all rap is and can be, and that's fine for jay-z, but we as a race shoudlnt be aspiring to be a nikka in paris, thats just degenerate

what kills me about it is then seeing jayz do shyt like this http://www.ballerstatus.com/2012/08...-frank-ocean-gwyneth-paltrows-summer-playlist using her to push chief keef and also nas saying she is real nikka and kanye acting like a shy 7th grader on the kardashians show, i cant respect these dudes as far as them leading rap culture, there are leading rap to a place that is not in the interest of the black race

Agree with everything, especially the bolded, but most folks will continue to ignore this, because they making money. Not knowing the damage this kinda thinking actually does to us.

I've never had a problem with Jay and his success, but it's this worshiping, and glorifying of Upper Class White culture, that sickens me.
 
Top