American Horror Story: Cult Discussion Thread

What's your favourite AHS?

  • Murder House

    Votes: 23 32.4%
  • Asylum

    Votes: 25 35.2%
  • Coven

    Votes: 14 19.7%
  • Freak Show

    Votes: 3 4.2%
  • Hotel

    Votes: 3 4.2%
  • Roanoke

    Votes: 3 4.2%

  • Total voters
    71

dora_da_destroyer

Master Baker
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
65,022
Reputation
15,922
Daps
266,189
Reppin
Oakland
I didn't get past that rape scene in the first episode
that set the tone all wrong for me from jump, i think i gave it 3 more eps, but it had too much depravity and "shock horror" along with a weak story. i'm mad they fukked it up cuz the setting was so dope.
 

StickStickly

Superstar
Joined
Nov 13, 2013
Messages
6,858
Reputation
1,640
Daps
19,940
that set the tone all wrong for me from jump, i think i gave it 3 more eps, but it had too much depravity and "shock horror" along with a weak story. i'm mad they fukked it up cuz the setting was so dope.
It's like they've been doing to this to every season though. Somehow they keep missing the mark. I thought Hotel was going to be dark and Roanoke was going to be better, but the opening sequences always wind up being more interesting than the story
 

DaylitoJames

#SnitchGang Elite
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
92,774
Reputation
29,450
Daps
291,870
Reppin
Sneak Nation
Ok so I'm rewatching the episode and I think I noticed something..... the scene where The Cult bust in Sally house to kill her. Notice how when Kai took off his mask and was typing Sally's suicide note on Facebook that in the background Beverly took off her mask as well and smiled in Sally's face like :troll:. When Sally saw Beverly's face she reacted like :dwillhuh::francis: which makes me think that Sally was set up. I'm thinking Beverly was the one to put the battery in the back of Sally to speak out against Kai and run against him because Beverly knew how Kai would react which is why he was like ":gucci: A write in vote?!" when he was confronted in that townhall meeting.
 

Deltron

The Return
Top Supporter
Supporter
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
48,755
Reputation
20,678
Daps
147,497
Reppin
The year 3030
It's like they've been doing to this to every season though. Somehow they keep missing the mark. I thought Hotel was going to be dark and Roanoke was going to be better, but the opening sequences always wind up being more interesting than the story

I'd say Roanoke did a better job overall sticking to a story and not diverting to random fukkery so much...before that Coven was probably the strongest story overall, ending was just ass and too happy
 

Heelmatic

The Carolina Blueprint
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
8,923
Reputation
1,141
Daps
16,699
Reppin
NC
Ok so I'm rewatching the episode and I think I noticed something..... the scene where The Cult bust in Sally house to kill her. Notice how when Kai took off his mask and was typing Sally's suicide note on Facebook that in the background Beverly took off her mask as well and smiled in Sally's face like :troll:. When Sally saw Beverly's face she reacted like :dwillhuh::francis: which makes me think that Sally was set up. I'm thinking Beverly was the one to put the battery in the back of Sally to speak out against Kai and run against him because Beverly knew how Kai would react which is why he was like ":gucci: A write in vote?!" when he was confronted in that townhall meeting.

I honestly didn’t read that much into it and just assumed she had that reaction because she knows her from the news. But you’re probably right because it’s never really that simple on this show.
 

Kinguno

The Immortal
Joined
Jan 11, 2017
Messages
14,903
Reputation
1,261
Daps
32,388
Reppin
New York
I'd say Roanoke did a better job overall sticking to a story and not diverting to random fukkery so much...before that Coven was probably the strongest story overall, ending was just ass and too happy

Roanoke was a show about a show within a show about a show

It was fukkery to the maximum and stole elements from get out
 
Top