Amani Toomer: Romo >>> Eli Manning

[23Barrettcity]

I still never said gb would have won the game i just said the score would have been closer if nikkas caught passes.

What i was getting at is that im not one of those nikkas that says if 10 different things change we win. Or if this and this and this happen we win.

We clearly lost the game but it wasnt arods fault nikkas was dropping passes like shyt.

ArOd wasn't sharp either , your team drops passes . The officials gave you a do over on a to and arod was forced to run more . Perry fewell said he wanted it that way take scrambles over long passes, plus the balls it takes for the hail manning pass to nix. We beat you stop making excuses I don't care about stats all I know is 2>1 sb MVP and rings

 

[Boutdatlife]

ArOd wasn't sharp either , your team drops passes . The officials gave you a do over on a to and arod was forced to run more . Perry fewell said he wanted it that way take scrambles over long passes, plus the balls it takes for the hail manning pass to nix. We beat you stop making excuses I don't care about stats all I know is 2>1 sb MVP and rings

I'll give you that jennings play bad call it can happen in any game but you are on bath salts if you think eli is better than a-rod fukk outta here.

Have 2 good back to back seasons first

A-rod is currently the most accurate passer in nfl history .

 

[23Barrettcity]

I'll give you that jennings play bad call it can happen in any game but you are on bath salts if you think eli is better than a-rod fukk outta here.

Have 2 good back to back seasons first

A-rod is currently the most accurate passer in nfl history .

Ehh I said I don't care about stats not one fukk is given to his accurate passing in history stat. Cool but how many rings he got ?

 

[Mantle Drunk]

This fukkin guy Toomer really Eli is without a doubt the best qb in the NFC East. He carried that team on his back for most of last year. Helped Victor Cruz emerge made Jake Ballard look good just wait and see Manningham this year total non factor I'm calling it now. His O-line at times sucked his runningbacks were awful for most of the year and the D was terrible intill the last couple of games of the season/playoffs. If that 49ers game doesnt prove he's a beast I dont know what will he impressed me that game most Qb's would of folded. Eli=Clutch.

 

[The Antagonist]

He know.

In all honesty though, what he said isn't really wrong. Some of you act like the Giants powerhoused their way to 2 Championships. they barely made it in last year. now granted.. Eli has been shown to be a clutch performer especially in the playoffs.. but Romo is the better statistical quarterback, and has more skill, at least in my eyes. It's his decision making and sometime lack of the clutch gene that ultimately kills Romo.

 

[23Barrettcity]

He know.

In all honesty though, what he said isn't really wrong. Some of you act like the Giants powerhoused their way to 2 Championships. Both times they barely made it in, now granted.. Eli has been shown to be a clutch performer especially in the playoffs.. but Romo is the better statistical quarterback, and has more skill, at least in my eyes. It's his decision making and sometime lack of the clutch gene that ultimately kills Romo.

All he has is better stats what tells you he has better skill? His choking ? His lack of playoff wins ? The way he can't make players better

 

[Akata Man Bromo]

 

[The Antagonist]

All he has is better stats what tells you he has better skill? His choking ? His lack of playoff wins ? The way he can't make players better

From September to November, Romo is Elite.

 

[HoLLaBaCK]

Romo has the better stats, however time and time again I hear the only stat that counts for QB's are W's & L's...except when it comes to Eli.

You can't compare Eli to Romo as they dont run the same offense. Eli runs one of the most difficult offense's to run which is the read & react. Which means no matter what the play call is Eli has to read the defense and change protections according to what he see's. Then based on what the WR see's he has to change his route...now the problem is both Eli and the WR have to read the same thing and both have to be on the same page as to what route the WR will now be running. shyts it's difficult to explain so u know its difficult to run.

Romo has one playoff win, Eli has 2 rings and 2 SB MVP's against arguably the greatest QB of this generation. I think that says who the better QB is.

Eli gets so much hate that people change up how you judge a QB with him. At one point dudes was talking like Eli was Trent Dilfer status. Damn near every year with Cowboys are predicted to be major players bc of their powerhouse offense. Eli goes on 2 win both rings with overlooked teams. Both SB runs he went thru the #1 & #2 teams in the NFC and the #1 in the AFC. Years from now Eli will get the credit he deserves.

 

[Carl Spackler]

He's about to catch the Tiki Barber treatment

 

[Lurker]

 

[23Barrettcity]

Romo has the better stats, however time and time again I hear the only stat that counts for QB's are W's & L's...except when it comes to Eli.

You can't compare Eli to Romo as they dont run the same offense. Eli runs one of the most difficult offense's to run which is the read & react. Which means no matter what the play call is Eli has to read the defense and change protections according to what he see's. Then based on what the WR see's he has to change his route...now the problem is both Eli and the WR have to read the same thing and both have to be on the same page as to what route the WR will now be running. shyts it's difficult to explain so u know its difficult to run.

Romo has one playoff win, Eli has 2 rings and 2 SB MVP's against arguably the greatest QB of this generation. I think that says who the better QB is.

Eli gets so much hate that people change up how you judge a QB with him. At one point dudes was talking like Eli was Trent Dilfer status. Damn near every year with Cowboys are predicted to be major players bc of their powerhouse offense. Eli goes on 2 win both rings with overlooked teams. Both SB runs he went thru the #1 & #2 teams in the NFC and the #1 in the AFC. Years from now Eli will get the credit he deserves.

Fantasy football is ruining football . Nothing but stats with these guys Eli beats the best teams but people don't care

 

[Joe Sixpack]

I really can't stand this fakkit Amani Toomer.. He wants so bad to be relevant and to work in the media, it's disgusting..

Of course he also is a c00n ass nicca who married a pinktoe who used him for college tuition..

'ABORT' SHOCK IN GIANT DIVORCE - NYPOST.com

 

[Rekkapryde]

Cowboys been stacked for years. Romo has had weapons out the wazoo, from TO to Austin to Bryant; Witten for years. Great running backs. Barber, both Jones', now this Murray kid. League leading sacker. Servicable back field. To be honest, every year I think it may be their year. They just make a lot of stupid mistakes and Romo is a participant in a good share of em.

Toomer lost points on this one.

I don't disagree with you. The one thing the Giants have easily had over Dallas is on the defensive side. Yeah Dallas has Ware, but that's it.

Romo's decision making is the biggest separator between him and Eli.

and yes, I'd take Eli over Romo.

 

[Jesus Shuttlesworth]

Attention whore