Of course, Hollywood can be confusing because someone can feel like an All-Star without ever having a good "season." Reynolds is the best example. His movie career started in 2001 with
Finder's Fee, a straight-to-DVD thriller he made while starring in
Two Guys, a Girl and a Pizza Place on ABC … a show that was more successful than you remember, staying on the air even after they jettisoned the pizza place and renamed it
Two Guys and a Girl. In 2002, he landed his first starring role, in National Lampoon's
Van Wilder. The good news: It made money, earned decent Rotten Tomatoes audience reviews (78 percent!)
7 and spawned an eventual sequel that nobody saw. The bad news: It wasn't that funny and ended up being sentenced to a lifetime of heavy edits on Comedy Central.
Our next five Reynolds movies: a supporting role in 2003's
The In-Laws (a remake of the Alan Arkin/Peter Falk classic that never should have happened); a starring role in 2003's
Foolproof (key words: "Canadian" and "straight to DVD"); a charming cameo in 2004's
Harold & Kumar Go to White Castle (overshadowed by Neil Patrick Harris's career-rejuvenating cameo); a supporting role in
Blade: Trinity (the last time anyone's seen Wesley Snipes in public); and then a starring role in a 2005 TV movie called
School of Life(created to fool anyone flipping channels into thinking it was
School of Rock).
By 2005, Hollywood liked Reynolds just enough that it gave him not one, not two, but THREE starring roles: the
Amityville Horror remake (21 percent approval rating from the Rotten Tomatoes top critics);
Waiting, an ensemble comedy about twenty something waiters that desperately wanted to be a
Dazed and Confused–like cult movie but never made it (24 percent); and
Just Friends, which was basically Fat Harry Meets Sally (37 percent) and featured Reynolds wearing a fat suit on the poster.