This 4th & 15 idea is way too gimmicky and borders on XFL teritory. If you're gonna get rid of kickoffs just put the ball at the 20.
I'm fine with it except for the 4th and 15 part.
Personally, I've always wanted to eliminate the following in football
- Protecting QB's - You either protect everyone or noone at all If the man has pads on like the other 21 players on the field you should be able to hit him just like every other player on the field. We need 22 football players on the field. Not 21 football players + 1 QB
- Punts - You either make it or you don't. You fail to make 10 yard the other team takes over on downs. Period
- Field goals - The object of the game is to score touchdowns by crossing the goal line. Just because you failed to do so doesnt mean you get to salvage 3 points out of said drive.
- Point after - In what other sport do you score and then get the chance to add to it without any penalty involved? Thats like scoring a basket and then getting free throw even tho you werent fouled.
Those rules protecting QBs are beyond necessary. Not only do they have the whole defense trying to destroy them, they're statues in the pocket a lot of the time that is happening. How does a QB protect himself in the moment after that pass is thrown? Or in the process of throwing it? And there are rules for the protection of every player on the field.
I hate the war analogies used in football, but they make sense. The game is made up of series of trying to gain your opponents territory. Strategy is a big part of that. Punting is part of the strategy. If you can't make it then punt and give the opponent a longer field.
The object of the game is to score more points than the other team. Field goals have been a way to score since the inception of the game. So I'm gonna need a better reason for getting rid of them than cats not liking kickers.
You don't get a free point in any other sport, cause they don't have that rule. What do other sports have to do with football? Again, you'll need a better reason to change a rule that's been a part of the game forever than not liking kickers.