Al Jahiz Superiority

I.AM.PIFF

You're minor, we're major
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
13,114
Reputation
11,670
Daps
40,758
Found this interesting.


On Africans in Arabia and Greater Syria, M.C. Zilfi says in Women and Slavery in the Late Ottoman Empire (2010):"Discrimination based on color was not unknown in these regions, but in many respects, black Africans seem not to have been worse off than free Arabs from the less pedigreed tribes. In any case, many free Arab tribesmen of long lineage were phenotypically indistinguishable from black Africans."

There has been black Africans and freed slaves ruling over Arabs as well (i.e. the Mamluks in Egypt)
 

I.AM.PIFF

You're minor, we're major
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
13,114
Reputation
11,670
Daps
40,758
IMO the Zanj and the Abyssinians were the Moors of East Africa, with their contribution, influence and sometimes dominance(Abyssinian).

Many people say that the Zanj revolt was a large slave rebellion, but many sources/historians argue that it was not due to there being a number of Zanj free people and how organized it was.

Yeah, a lot of free blacks resided in the region and a number of Arabs also participated in the revolts it seems :ld:
 

Bawon Samedi

Good bye Coli
Supporter
Joined
Mar 28, 2014
Messages
42,413
Reputation
18,635
Daps
166,512
Reppin
Good bye Coli(2014-2020)
There has been black Africans and freed slaves ruling over Arabs as well (i.e. the Mamluks in Egypt)

I'm aware of that. Most people don't know.

You should check this out.
51By7BAdIGL._BO2,204,203,200_PIsitb-sticker-v3-big,TopRight,0,-55_SX278_SY278_PIkin4,BottomRight,1,22_AA300_SH20_OU01_.jpg

Product Description
In the 9th and 10th centuries enslaved East Africans were brought to the Ziyadid kingdom of Yemen. By the later 10th century they had become the Prime Ministers of the kingdom. One of the last such Prime Ministers formed a dynasty that was to last for almost a hundred and fifty years, repeatedly bouncing back from the political intrigue of their Arab neighbours. Zabid was the capital from which they ruled and is today a UNESCO World Heritage site. They were renowned builders and protectors of the architectural heritage of Yemen.

Slave To King: The African Rulers of Medieval Yemen is a book that tells a little known part of the history of Africans in Asia and of slavery as a whole. While telling this story it also bravely asserts that enslaved foreigners have earned the moral right to rule any land which they have helped to build. It also looks at the various attitudes that Arabs had towards Africans and how the latter managed to literally rise above them. A must read for those interested in an African history that stands tall and bows to none

Man the Zanj and Abyssinians were literally EVERYWHERE!!! Even as far as China! The Zanj before Islam were even trading with the Romans and maybe Greeks.
 

Bawon Samedi

Good bye Coli
Supporter
Joined
Mar 28, 2014
Messages
42,413
Reputation
18,635
Daps
166,512
Reppin
Good bye Coli(2014-2020)
Yeah, a lot of free blacks resided in the region and a number of Arabs also participated in the revolts it seems :ld:
Indeed, but you should check this out....

M. A. Shaban's Islamic History: A.D. 750-1055 (A.H. 132-448) in the section "Regional Economic Conflicts":

"All the talk about slaves rising against the wretched conditions of work in the salt marshes of Basra is a figment of the imagination and has no support in the sources. [...] The vast majority of the rebels were Arabs of the Persian Gulf supported by free East Africans who had made their homes in the region [...] If more proof is needed that it was not a slave revolt, it is to be found in the fact that it had a highly organized army and navy which vigorously resisted the whole weight of the central government for almost fifteen years.Moreover, it must have had huge resources that allowed it to build no less than six impregnable towns in which there were arsenals for the manufacture of weapons and battleships. These towns also had in their mammoth markets prodigious wealth which was more than the salt marshes could conceivably produce. Even all the booty from Basra and the whole region could not account for such enormous wealth.Significantly the revolt had the backing of a certain group of merchants who persevered with their support until the very end. Tabari makes it very clear that the strength of the rebels was dependent on the support of these merchants."

"With remarkable efficiency and expedition the rebels swiftly established their control over most of the Persian Gulf coast, and extended it inland to secure their food supplies. Special vehemence was reserved for the port of Basra, which they practically destroyed. Their choice of sites for their own new towns and their meticulous knowledge of the intricate waterways of the region in addition to their great skill in naval warfare were all utilized to strangle the Basran economy and drive all the in-coming trade through their own channels."
 

Sinnerman

Veteran
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
32,540
Reputation
4,436
Daps
64,709
I think your more knowledgeable than me on the Zanj rebellion and Muslim African history in general, do you think the Zanj rebellion wasn't really a slave one?

In my opinion? No. This is due to the fact that the first mention of it being a slave revolt came relatively recently right? Even this superiority document makes no mention of a slave revolt

Although do you think it could have been a slave revolt that was then exploited by east african merchants for their benefit?

I'm going to buy this book soon http://books.google.ca/books/about/The_revolt_of_the_Zanj.html?id=-ctgf6WSCPMC&redir_esc=y

it details the event from a contemporary source
 

Bawon Samedi

Good bye Coli
Supporter
Joined
Mar 28, 2014
Messages
42,413
Reputation
18,635
Daps
166,512
Reppin
Good bye Coli(2014-2020)
In my opinion? No. This is due to the fact that the first mention of it being a slave revolt came relatively recently right? Even this superiority document makes no mention of a slave revolt

Although do you think it could have been a slave revolt that was then exploited by east african merchants for their benefit?

I'm going to buy this book soon http://books.google.ca/books/about/The_revolt_of_the_Zanj.html?id=-ctgf6WSCPMC&redir_esc=y

it details the event from a contemporary source

Thanks!

But the Zanj revolt is very confusing, especially when you bring up East African merchants. Slave revolt or not I hear that the Zanj/blacks werent the majority but were funded by East African merchants other times I hear they were the majority, thought its usually when the revolt is labeled as a "slave revolt". Which one is it? And if the Zanj weren't the majority than why was the revolt named after them???

And are the blacks in Iraq/Iran mostly descendants of slaves?
 
Top