Doesn't look terrible
I'll say this though: shyt been in development so long, Danielson in the game has short hair and current Danielson has hair to his shoulders. Statlander in the game still an alien, current Statlander done blown her knee out, went back to her home planet to rehab, got exiled back to earth and came back a whole ass regular person.
The development time hurt this a lot. It isn't even out yet and it feels frozen in time. They need to hire someone to sit with the character customizer they talked about and just customize everyone in the game into
who they are currently so you can release a Day 1 patch with the game.
Having throwback gameplay with throwback graphics would be a hard sell to plenty of people as it is; having it be throwback rosters on top of it... might as well just play an emulator of an old WWE game.