Sarah Jessica Parker was cute around the time of L.A. Story, Honeymoon in Vegas, etc....Her horse-face just became more pronounced as she got older.
Most of these girls I think were hot in more than one movie. Anne Hathaway was bad in TDKR, but have you ever seen Havoc?
I definitely agree with Cameron Diaz peaking in The Mask, there's probably other movies around that time period I never saw where she looked good. I can't count her though because I also liked her in that bondage soft-core movie she did,