[3/25/18] New Japan Pro Wrestling Presents: Strong Style Evolved!

OmegaK2099

Gettin' It In
Joined
May 23, 2012
Messages
33,313
Reputation
3,680
Daps
52,963
Someone rank the matches from best to worst, im interested to see how youd rate this show :lupe:
 

The Rainmaker

Mr. Money in the Bank
Joined
Jun 12, 2012
Messages
31,703
Reputation
5,361
Daps
133,626
Someone rank the matches from best to worst, im interested to see how youd rate this show :lupe:

Meltzer star ratings:

SHO/Yoh/Rocky v Daniels/Kazarian/Sky 3.25

Robinson/Finlay v Goto/Gedo 2.25

Archer/Smith Jr v Yano/Chucky T 3.25

Cody/Scurrl v Tonga/Loa 3.25

Naito/Sanada/Bushi/Takahashi v Tanahashi/Kushida/Taguchi/Lee 3.75

Ospreay v Liger 3.75

Suzuki/Sabre Jr v Ishii/Okada 4

White v Page 3.75

Omega/Ibushi v Matt/Nick Jackson 5
 

stro

Superstar
Joined
May 18, 2015
Messages
10,020
Reputation
1,175
Daps
29,212
Reppin
Indiana
I'd lower all those scores by AT LEAST a star, except for Ishii/Tanahashi vs Suzuki/ZSJ, which seems pretty accurately pegged at 4 stars. I read that Meltzer and Alvarez discussed that if you have to think about if a match is 5 stars, then it isn't 5 stars, and they had to think about GL vs YB, therefore it wasn't 5 stars....then gave it 5 stars anyway :russ:
 

stro

Superstar
Joined
May 18, 2015
Messages
10,020
Reputation
1,175
Daps
29,212
Reppin
Indiana
:myman:Putting Dave Meltzer on the payroll was one of the smartest decisions Bullet Club has ever made :smugdraper: he who controls the media controls the narrative

Lol I'd love to read a transcript of him hemming and hawing over how he isn't biased towards NJPW despite showing up on their streaming service doing coverage for them directly.
 

Cheercomp

Pro
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
1,298
Reputation
230
Daps
2,141
Reppin
NULL
Rewatching the event now and I seriously am tired of JR's commentary. Highly overrated at this point, cringe worthy at best, and at times felt like he was belittling the product.
 

Jmare007

pico pal q lee
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,226
Reputation
5,830
Daps
108,631
Reppin
Chile
I'd lower all those scores by AT LEAST a star, except for Ishii/Tanahashi vs Suzuki/ZSJ, which seems pretty accurately pegged at 4 stars. I read that Meltzer and Alvarez discussed that if you have to think about if a match is 5 stars, then it isn't 5 stars, and they had to think about GL vs YB, therefore it wasn't 5 stars....then gave it 5 stars anyway :russ:

Well, you know, 5 stars is not 5 stars anymore. I mean, you know, 5 stars is still 5 stars in the sense that it's still an amazing match that's up there with the best of them. But you know what I mean? After Omega and Okada had that 6 stars match, the bar has been set up high, so a 5 stars match is still incredible but it's not an all time match. I mean, I went back and changed the rating for other matches and gave it 6 stars. I mean, it's not that difficult, I've explained it before.


:lolbron:

White vs Page getting 3.75 is as funny as that time a couple of years ago when he gave an Orton match that was a snore fest 4 stars just because he loves Randy :heh:
 
Top