2024 PWI 500

mannyrs13

Compound Kingpin
Supporter
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
39,908
Reputation
15,722
Daps
87,991
Reppin
Focusville, USA
Is this based on wrestling or relevancy on the programming?

Maybe it's just me but I just don't see anything special from Cody, especially since winning the title. I guess the chase and storyline helped him. Not saying there's the argument of him vs Swerve. But even in WWE there are guys like Gunther and others who may have a case especially as better wrestlers.

Just feels like Cody has gotten repetitive with his feuds and overall reign. Not taking away anything from his accomplishments but I don't believe he would be first if he would've never became champ.

Rest of the WWE list looks decent, and some well deserved recognition for Trick and Ilja.


Interesting announcers list. Nigel a riot with his Danielson hate. Good to see Menard get some recognition, think he's the least experienced on here. Was wondering why gotta like Michael Cole weren't on and realized he play by play instead.
 

Cattle Mutilation

Superstar
Joined
Dec 7, 2016
Messages
27,472
Reputation
1,226
Daps
42,447
Is this based on wrestling or relevancy on the programming?

Maybe it's just me but I just don't see anything special from Cody, especially since winning the title. I guess the chase and storyline helped him. Not saying there's the argument of him vs Swerve. But even in WWE there are guys like Gunther and others who may have a case especially as better wrestlers.

Just feels like Cody has gotten repetitive with his feuds and overall reign. Not taking away anything from his accomplishments but I don't believe he would be first if he would've never became champ.

Rest of the WWE list looks decent, and some well deserved recognition for Trick and Ilja.


Interesting announcers list. Nigel a riot with his Danielson hate. Good to see Menard get some recognition, think he's the least experienced on here. Was wondering why gotta like Michael Cole weren't on and realized he play by play instead.
It’s basically based on all kayfabe aspects as well as the individual’s abilities apart from booking (like in-ring ability, promo cutting skills, etc.)
 

KFBF

Superstar
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
10,210
Reputation
1,886
Daps
30,468
Reppin
Eagle, Colorado
@Tres Leches @KateFabersBoyfriend


seth-rollins-dance.gif
People thought vanilla ice was great too.
 

mannyrs13

Compound Kingpin
Supporter
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
39,908
Reputation
15,722
Daps
87,991
Reppin
Focusville, USA
Gunther should be number 2 or at least 3:mjlol:

Roman
Cody
Gunther

Is how it should’ve been

Roman last fought at Mania and hasn't been active for half the time this list was relevant. Even before he wasn't wrestling as much. I doubt he should be on here or who knows if he'll ever even be top 5 again.
 
Top