2024-25 Contract Season

Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
70,289
Reputation
11,768
Daps
246,464
Reppin
206 & 734
Rhea is the only star out of those names and people like her because she has a phat ass and looks “cool.” :skip:

Aside from GUNTHER and Rhea, Every other talent you listed has yet to have an impact or treated like a big deal for many months. Being over isn’t enough if the booking isnt consistently good.

Edit: and I don’t think it was Trips who elevated those 2 when it was Cokeboy who started it off. Trips just kept it going. Maybe GUNTHER, but he won the IC title under Cokeboy.
Yeah I'm not discussing this further the way you're purposefully narrowing the goalposts so aggressively to be "right"
 

MenacingMonk

Tranquilo
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
63,252
Reputation
8,073
Daps
137,548
Reppin
West where the Sunsets
Priest been a world champ, Solo main evented a big 4 ppv and carried a whole storyline for a few months. Wtf do you even be talking about lmao

Reread my post. I said treated like a big deal for many months. None of those wrestlers have dominated or been pushed as consistently as Rhea or GUNTHER. Having a reign here and there doesn’t mean shyt if they’re not booked with consistency.

Iyo, Priest and LA been moved back to midcard after losing their belts. Iyo back in the title pic, but we all know she’s just there to put over Rhea.

Dom in the same position he’s been in a year ago.

Solo only in his spot because of the Bloodline.

I don’t count Paul because he’s basically an attraction.

:mjlol: at acting like headlining Summerslam is some flex.
 
Last edited:

Brad Piff

The Money & The Miles
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
19,998
Reputation
2,811
Daps
57,904
Reppin
San Diego
Priest been a world champ, Solo main evented a big 4 ppv and carried a storyline for a few months. Wtf do you even be talking about lmao

Yeah I'm not discussing this further the way you're purposefully narrowing the goalposts so aggressively to be "right"
guy is a certified bozo

or in a word he can better understand, pendejo.
 

MenacingMonk

Tranquilo
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
63,252
Reputation
8,073
Daps
137,548
Reppin
West where the Sunsets
Yeah I'm not discussing this further the way you're purposefully narrowing the goalposts so aggressively to be "right"
How am I narrowing goalposts? I never said they all have to be stars. I get that. I’m saying their booking is inconsistent. Giving them a reign as champ only to be treated like a midcarder after losing is the issue.
 

MenacingMonk

Tranquilo
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
63,252
Reputation
8,073
Daps
137,548
Reppin
West where the Sunsets
Swerve is a perfect example of a wrestler who has been booked well after losing the belt:

-restarted Hangman feud.
-was used to introduce Lashley and THS.
-in a hot feud with Rico.

He may have lost the matches, but that’s not the point. It’s the fact he’s been booked in programs that are interesting.
 

TL15

Veteran
Joined
Mar 4, 2015
Messages
16,737
Reputation
13,743
Daps
136,440
Ricky is a star. Tony fumbled this one.

No diss and none of the internet troll or whatever, just curious why this is the take because I really don’t see it (but am open to being wrong/hearing how I’m wrong)

Is it his charisma (I’ve never noticed anything outside of AEW but that fan base seems to cheer for everything)

Is it his ring work (seemed normal - not bad not amazing)

What exactly is it that makes him “a star”?
 

br82186

Superstar
Joined
Jul 3, 2018
Messages
14,152
Reputation
1,452
Daps
43,576
damn they wasted no time lmao good for starks im happy to see him shine. they gonna make MJF regret not signing.
With the money he signed for and they'll still have interest once his contract is up, he good.
 

Cattle Mutilation

Superstar
Joined
Dec 7, 2016
Messages
28,404
Reputation
1,281
Daps
43,795
No diss and none of the internet troll or whatever, just curious why this is the take because I really don’t see it (but am open to being wrong/hearing how I’m wrong)

Is it his charisma (I’ve never noticed anything outside of AEW but that fan base seems to cheer for everything)

Is it his ring work (seemed normal - not bad not amazing)

What exactly is it that makes him “a star”?
He's average in the ring and above average to good on the mic, so he's a good fit for WWE style. A much better fit for WWE than AEW.
 
Top