i see nothing wrong with Michelle being in the top 20/15
15 Greatest Smackdown Stars Ever
- Thread starter R=G
- Start date
Cena and JBL are too low. The new day and Orton shouldn’t be on this list. Brock was the headliner and one of the main reasons why smackdown was so great during the 02-04 run so he needs to be in the top 5. I’d put Edge in the top three for being arguably the greatest heel in smackdown history. Overall not a bad list tho 
He might be the goatAJ already number 3
NOSaintsFan02
Superstar
Ain't no universe where the Usos are a top 10 SD talent.
Great run and longevity they've had, but they will NOT be considered top 10 talents for the Smackdown eras years from now when people reflect on the history of the show.
New Day too actually. The New Day had a better run on RAW. The New Day/Uso rivalry was great for SD, but not enough to put them top 10.
Eh. These lists are all subjective anyways.
Great run and longevity they've had, but they will NOT be considered top 10 talents for the Smackdown eras years from now when people reflect on the history of the show.
New Day too actually. The New Day had a better run on RAW. The New Day/Uso rivalry was great for SD, but not enough to put them top 10.
Eh. These lists are all subjective anyways.
Brock was most pushed...the reason? Nah....Cena and JBL are too low. The new day and Orton shouldn’t be on this list. Brock was the headliner and one of the main reasons why smackdown was so great during the 02-04 run so he needs to be in the top 5. I’d put Edge in the top three for being arguably the greatest heel in smackdown history. Overall not a bad list tho
Redwood
Superstar
Kurt should be higher than AJ 
cartierhoe
Veteran
List needs Brock
prophecypro
Hollywood North
I get why 02 revival Hollywood Hogan, Benoit and Straight Edge CM Punk arent on there
But no Brock Lesnar and Jeff Hardy?
But no Brock Lesnar and Jeff Hardy?
He wasnt a great wrestler. He was in the ring with all time great wrestlers..Eddie, Rey, Rocky, Angle, etc. He played a good monster heel and he is up there with Rock/Shelton/Angle one of the fastest in ring learners ever. The Gowen stuff was funny...much better on the mic back then too. But he wasnt outworking anyone significant except Raw guys. WGTT were having excellent matches every fukking week...Benjamin was such a great heel tag worker. He was always harassing someone behind someone's back.Current brock Lesnar is a lazy part timer, but prime Brock was legit a great wrestler. He has more classic matches and segments on smackdown than most of the people on the official list. He was most pushed because he was that good
If you put Lesnar on the list, maybe around 7 or 8 at the most. That's about it. He was never ever the best at any time.
And he was most pushed because Rock went to Hollywood and they qent with him over ultra over RVD and multiple others. They were being cute..keeping him away from Cripple H and doing the Taker job two months str8. Slick shyt. shyt u see today with the Shield guys basically.
Last edited:
This ain't real wrestling nyggaDude was an NCAA wrestling champion but wasn’t a great wrestler. Okay.
Agree to disagree fam
This is a give and take deal. Performing. That's how u get Rey beating Nash and Big Show..wtf is wrong with u? Lesnar can do alot in college but never did any of that in the ring. He was a suplex guy who relied on strength spots and his opponents selling his character. That's it. Hes not half the wrestler of Savage or Eddie. Not even close. Hes done great for his push...and they pushed him on size..not because he could work classic matches.