That's not a challenge, that's a hassle. The fact that the portable version of Persona 3 has a much more intuitive menu system says it all. Many times I'd be outside at Paulonia Mall fresh out the weapon shop and I'd have weapons but due to the design of the game, I'd have to go all the way to Tartarus and then "press x" in front of the character who's items I want to switch out. that's annoying. Why can't I just equip my items and look at stats like most other RPG games without having to physically have the person there? If you're talking about the actual more in depth battle system than I agree it's better since physical attacks have three categories but that's not what I was talking about. It's just how clunky the menu's are that annoys me.
Story in P4 terrible and drawn out?? The story was very interesting and it being a detective story made it all the more relatable.
The story in 3 is very drawn out breh lol. I'm 70 hours into Persona 3 and the story doesn't really kick off until about September/October and even then it gets very formulaic(Wait until full moon of each month and destroy shadow.) The story in Persona 4 takes a back seat often with the characters and other events taking the stage at times but the character performance and dialogue is so well done that it doesn't bother me.
The story in P3 is way more serious so If someone is into dark settings I can see why they'd prefer it but the pacing of the game ruins the story for me. I always felt like I wanted to hurry up and get through the day to get on to the story which brings me to a another point... The characters... The characters imo are straight up boring compared to Persona 4 characters then again it might be due to me just preferring the more jovial fun theme of Persona 4.
I played Persona 3 FIRST so it's not like I played 4 and then 3 and saying 4 is better but to me... There's hardly anyone in Persona 3 that's interesting. Junpei is like a cornier version of Yosuke, Yukari is a bland version of Chie, Fuuka is like that band girl from Persona 4(Ayane) and Mitsuro is like a classier version of Yukiko. The only characters I kind of liked in Persona 3 is my nikka Aigis and Shinjiro somewhat. The S links in Persona 3 were also wack imo. The dialogue just wasn't hitting me like they were in Persona 4. Junpei and his constant simping of Chidori was cringe worthy.
The music in Persona 3 is also far more repetitive. The fact that there's only one theme song after school all the way until you reach a new season is wack while Persona 4 had a song for the different weather patterns. As you can see,lol I put a lot of times into both games and imo Persona 3 is just wacker to me.
Don't even get me started on the horrible abomination they call Tartarus.
It's alright but I just find the flaws way too glaring after coming off of Persona 4.