IllmaticDelta
Veteran
A geneological breakdown example of the Lumbee and other triracial/indian groups in the Carolinas and the Aframs in the same region
Reuben Mainor
Reuben Mainor/Maynor
Reuben Mainor appears to have spent most of his life in Sampson County NC. Frank Mainor, one of his descendants, believes that Reuben and his wife Elizabeth were "Indians" originally from Robeson County; that they had to leave Robeson because they killed a White man over some land dispute. He also stated that Elizabeth was a Manuel (maiden name).
The Sketch of Classified Indians of Sampson County pamphlet originally published in 1921 by the tribe holds the genealogy of Reuben Mainor and Elizabeth Manuel. Reuben was the son of John Mainor. Reuben had at least three siblings: Jack, Bob, and Sampson. Brothers Bob, Sampson, and Reuben Mainor married sisters America, Loney, and Elizabeth/Lizzie Manuel.
Elizabeth Manuel and her sisters were daughters of Shade and Zilpha Manuel. Shade had married Zilpha Hardin – as well as Zilpha’s sister, Dicy Hardin. Zilpha and Dicy were the children of Si Hardin. Shade Manuel was the son of Nicholas Manuel and Millie Hale, grandson of Ephriam Manuel and great-grandson of Nicholas Manuel the first.
It is true that both Mainor and Manuel are surnames in what is today recognized as the Lumbee Indian tribe based in Robeson County, NC. The two particular surnnmmes and others, such as Hardin and Brewington, were more prevalent in the free colored population of Sampson County in the time frame in which Reuben Mainor lived. Today's Lumbee Indians, the Sampson County Coharie Indians, and the Colored/Negro/Black Sampson/New Hanover NC County families named Mainor, West, Jacobs, Brewington, Williams, Manuel are descended from the same mixed race group of people that have lived in the area since at least the 1700's. The Lumbee/Coharie/Mainor/West/Jacobs/Brewington/Williams/Manuel ancestors have always been visibly Native American, yet varying in color, features, and hair texture enough that African and European influence could not be denied.
There are many books on the struggle of the Lumbee people to gain tribal recognition from Whites and from other, more organized, recognized Indian peoples. This struggle culiminated in the tribe gaining official recognition and a name in the late 1880's. At that time persons exhibiting the physical characteristics and surnames of the loose-knit clans could declare their Indian-ness and join the tribe. These people were thereafter reclassified from "mulatto" to "Indian" on censuses and other records.
The Sampson County people followed the same pattern; there are just fewer published documents attesting to the fact. In the 1880’s through the 1920’s, the people began to claim their Indian heritage and subsequently restricted their affiliation with kindred who did not do likewise. Even the spellings of Manuel/Emmanuel and Mainor/Maynor are believed to have arisen in this time period as a way to distinguish tribesmen from non-tribesmen.
For the people who chose not to join the tribe, they carried the "mulatto" designation on censuses until the early 1920's, at which time they began to be counted with other Blacks. So there are sets of third cousins in Sampson County and between Sampson and New Hanover Counties who are “Black” on one side of the family and “Indian” on the other. Some of the older relatives remember the kinship. Many of the younger do not.
The family of Reuben and Elizabeth Mainor reflect this phenomena perfectly. Five of their children married into one free colored family in the 1860’s and 1870’s. These children and their descendants seemed not to have joined the tribe at its incorporation. They consider themselves African American today. At least two more of Reuben and Elizabeth’s children married their Mainor cousins. It appears that these descendants are affiliated as Coharie Indians today.
An R. Mainer appears in the 1840 Sampson County census. The household consisted of two free colored males from aged 10-25, one free colored male from 55-99, and one free colored female from 55-99. A John Mainer and an S. Mayner are also listed. This was probably Reuben, his father John, and brother Sampson.
Reuben Mainor