Will A MVP and/or Superbowl win make Peyton Manning the undisputed GOAT QB?

[Splatter©]

New team, new city, rebuilding his system with only 2 players having played in it before, off 4 neck surgeries, only with 75% of his arm strength left, leading all time great combacks already, Top 5 in all stats,

He is the system

 

[Street Knowledge]

He Still wouldn't have the best resume.

 

[SEC Hater]

He already is the undisputed GOAT in my eyes

 

[A Friend of The People]

He Still wouldn't have the best resume.

5 MVPS, 2 SB's 3/appearances = The GOAT off top breh

He has 3/4 more years to get there, since Brady is on the fall off nobody else will ever get to that standard

 

[A Friend of The People]

He already is the undisputed GOAT in my eyes

enjoy these full green bars breh

 

[Stone]

The way the Pats lost in those Super Bowls reaffirms my belief that SBs are not really the greatest judgement. Brady put them in position to win and factors outside of his control ultimately caused the lost. Just like there were factors not in his control that helped him win the three that he did. Just like Manning put the Colts in position to win some playoff games and they still lost, and sometimes they won in spite of a poor performance from him.

Manning has his name in the hat so just be happy with that, and I'm saying this with Peyton being my favorite player of any sport.

 

[jetflyinglimousineriding]

At least he might be able to enjoy his MVP award watching the SB at home

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

At least he might be able to enjoy his MVP award watching the SB at home

He aint the MVP either

 

[jetflyinglimousineriding]

He aint the MVP either

Nah, voting was done before playoffs. They're going to give it to him even though I'd like AD to get it