Lots of in-ring charisma. Does his best to make the other side look good no matter who it is (looking at you, Ryder) Oversells even the littlest moves like a simple monkey flip just to give us that "holy shyt" moment. Does this no matter where he is on the card or if he's winning or jobbing (usually the latter.)
Live mic work obviously lacks but when put to the real test solo, can come through (AJ locker room ether comes to mind.) People bring up his offence, or lackthereof.. little tough to showcase that when you're selling for 90% of a match just to make the other guy look good.
That night after WM pop