Who won this trade?

[Mantle Drunk]

Pretty big argument going on in one of my leagues right now on who got the better of the deal.

Peterson/Harvin/foster
For
Lacey/dez/Tate

Most people are thinking its robbery for the guy getting ap/Percy/foster but the way I see it is a guy getting dez by disguising it with big name backs but getting back comparable or almost equal value backs.

 

[McTwerk]

Seems fair to me.

Peterson is better than Lacy, but Dez >>>> than Harvin.
Foster and Tate is a wash.

I am sure cause it involves AP people are up in arms, but if the guy getting Dez likes him more with Lacy than he does AP\Harvin, then what the problem is?

 

[Spaceman Piff]

I'm guessing ben tate?

I'd rather have the lacy/dez/tate side but it looks pretty even to me.

 

[BreezyH]

lacy/dez/tate won that

peterson is a beast and foster has a favorable schedule tho

 

[#StarkSet]

Pretty big argument going on in one of my leagues right now on who got the better of the deal.

Peterson/Harvin/foster
For
Lacey/dez/Tate

Most people are thinking its robbery for the guy getting ap/Percy/foster but the way I see it is a guy getting dez by disguising it with big name backs but getting back comparable or almost equal value backs.

actually trade is fair as shyt

 

[The Fukin Prophecy]

This trade reeks of Foster fear mongering...

Lacey and Tate in no way shape or form compare to AP and a healthy Foster...That's a big downgrade...

I would take my chances with Foster, I feel his injury history is overblown...Dude looked good last season when he played and was on pace for his usual monster season...If Foster does play 16 games this season you will regret trading him and I'll bet my left nut the dude you traded him to will win your league...AP and Foster can easily put up 1500 yards with 10-15 TD...

You'd be lucky to get 1000 and 7 out of Ben Tate...

 

[Mantle Drunk]

This trade reeks of Foster fear mongering...

Lacey and Tate in no way shape or form compare to AP and a healthy Foster...That's a big downgrade...

I would take my chances with Foster, I feel his injury history is overblown...Dude looked good last season when he played and was on pace for his usual monster season...If Foster does play 16 games this season you will regret trading him and I'll bet my left nut the dude you traded him to will win your league...AP and Foster can easily put up 1500 yards with 10-15 TD...

You'd be lucky to get 1000 and 7 out of Ben Tate...

Not my trade just a trade I thought was fair that had the league in an outrage to the tune of 72 texts in a group message by the time I looked. Just thought it was more fair then the rest of the league wanted to see what the coli's thoughts were on it. After Thursday I'm starting to think dude got hosed as well.