Who is the better artist? Mya or Ashanti?

[SupaVillain]

Both artists have been recognized by their light but strong vocals over pop beats, but who you do think is the better singer?
Mya






Ashanti






Personally, I gotta give my point to Ashanti. She'd had been ghostwriting for J.Lo and had a crazy debut album.

 

[I'm Blackman]

Ashanti fine.....but Mya just look tasty.


















































Uhh I guess I like Mya music better too. Ashanti had the harder hits....but I prefer Myas voice.

 

[Jaylen Tatum]

Ashanti

 

[KnickstapeCity]

A young @KnickstapeCity ruined a many white Hanes boxers self pleasuring to the sweet visuals of that Rock Wit U video.

 

[SupaVillain]

re-listening to both of their debut albums, Mya clearly had a better album now that I'm going back to it. Having Dru Hill produce and write your shyt was definitely a cheat code

 

[BEN23]

THERE BOTH GOOD...cant decide

 

[Solo_87]

Strong vocals?

Prefer Ashanti though I enjoy some of Mya's music

 

[erker]

Don't like their music very much, but both of their bodies though

Mya takes it in that regard.

 

[rabbid]

 

[DontEemTry]

In no way shape or form is Myas catalogue ever fukking with Ashantis.

I don't even care that Ashanti has limited talent. She got bangers.

 

[JustCKing]

I've liked more Mya songs than I have Ashanti:

It's All About Me- Mya in that video had me crushing

Movin' On feat. Silkk- I still feel Britney Spears bit this video for "One More Time".

Best of Me Remix

Girls Dem Sugar

Case of the Ex

 

[Artificial Intelligence]

Ashanti..

 

[trillanova]

Mya

 

[Unbothered]

Great singers but they're both kinda equal to me.

I played both of their songs back-to-back, and neither one of them has a distinctive enough voice that separates them. If I didn't know better and played them blindly, I'd probably confuse them both.

Mary J. Blige, for example, has a distinctive voice, and so does Erykah Badu, so I would be able to identify them both.

 

[Dboy41]

Mya is better.



Ashanti heavily relied on samples.