Which one of these fighters would Pretty Boy Floyd beat in their prime?

[Quarterback]

Even if any of these were never a Jr Middleweight, so what. Just say what would happen if he faced them when they were Jr Middleweights, or in their prime.

 

[Amare's Right Hook]

David Tua

 

[Champ_KW]

Floyd beats everybody in your poll.

 

[Skip b]

Neither the answer is someone who will rough him up you aren't gonna outs kill Mayweather even the Leanards would have issues matching that.

Hopkins is the answer, a guy that could rough him up and wont allow him to create distance, the weight difference may disqualify him from this discussion, although he made 158 for ODH.....

 

[R=G]

Whitaker and Hearns are true hard fights...Hearns is pretty damn tall for that division. And he would DEFINITELY use his height to keep things interesting.

 

[So UnThotful]

David Tua

 

[yo moms]

Hearns is a serious threat with that range and power.

Haggler is a full blown middleweight.

 

[Quarterback]

Hearns is a serious threat with that range and power.

Haggler is a full blown middleweight.

Hagler was 157 in a coupla fights. Pit Hagler at his lightest vs Floyd at his heaviest.

 

[yo moms]

Hagler was 157 in a coupla fights. Pit Hagler at his lightest vs Floyd at his heaviest.

I feel like Hagler would have a better chance if the fight was 15 rounds.

 

[King P]

SLR
Hearns
Pernell Whitaker
Duran would win at 135, but at the higher weights he'd lose.

Even Oscar in his prime wouldn't beat Floyd. Chavez would look silly. Meldrick Taylor & Hector Camacho (at 135) would give Floyd a Judah-like run for his money, but ultimately come up short.

I'm not even counting Hagler or Barkley

 

[Reggie]

I think Hagler and Hearns would have eventually got to him and knocked him out if they fought. Especially the Hitman with that power and reach. I think him and Leonard would be a very good fight and could go either way. But out of all these fictional fights I think I would like to see Taylor and Floyd before any other one.