What's the better show: Penny Dreadful, American Horror Story or Hemlock Grove?

[Dominic Brehetto]

Been meaning to start all of these but was curious what the coli consensus is on them. Any of them not worth watching or absolute piff?

 

[BlackAchilles]

Without even watching the others, American Horror Story. It's not "scary" per se, but it's really dark, racy, has great stories, plenty of funny/weird/fukkery moments, and always keeps me wanting more.

Also, Jessica Lange has become my favorite actress off the strength this show.

 

[kp404]

Penny Dreadful is the only watchable one right now...American Horror Story always starts strong, then turns terrible in the final episodes...I'm giving it one more season to be good then I'm done
The less said about that turd Hemlock Grove, the better :jayleaves:

 

[Jello Biafra]

1. Penny Dreadful - this is a well written, well acted show that got better as the season went alng and features some truly memorable characters

2. American Horror Story - this show is enjoyable just for the fukkery that its creators throw out there every episode

3. Hemlock Grove - I am mad I wasted my time watching Season 2 especially after that shytty last episode

 

[Dank Hill]

AHS

 

[BlackAchilles]

I may have to check Penny Dreadful out

 

[Rich Spirit]

I need to catch up on Penny Dreadful. Only watched like 3 episodes but it was good from what i watched.

 

[FlyRy]

I may have to check Penny Dreadful out

Eva Green was outstanding in it

and it was good to see hartnett after he went MIA after 30 days of night

it was predictable, but i give it a solid 7/10. i think season 2 will up the fukkery

 

[SlowPaceThrillah]

"Banshee", obviously

 

[Danie84]

Penny Dreadful, is like reading Edgar Allen Poe; a slow buildup to dark mayhem fukkery

...AHS starts out great (on the strength of Jessica Lange), then gets silly, and I've never seen Hemlock Grove

 

[STAN JONES]

im not finished the season yet but so far "Salem" is better than the 3 shows you named

I'd rank them:

1.Salem
2.Penny Dreadful

3.American Horror Story








































4.Hemlock Grove`

 

[prophecypro]

Penny>>AHS>>Hemlock and Salem is just above Hemlock tbh

 

[Dominic Brehetto]

Penny Dreadful, is like reading Edgar Allen Poe...a slow buildup to dark mayhem fukkery

...AHS starts out great (on the strength of Jessica Lange), then gets silly. And, I never seen Hemlock Grove

This sold me on pd. I love poe.

 

[Blaze007]

I'm the only one that fukked with Hemlock Grove huh???

I could see how people wouldn't like it but I enjoyed it.

 

[Dominic Brehetto]

I'm the only one that fukked with Hemlock Grove huh???

I could see how people wouldn't like it but I enjoyed it.

Season 1 44% metacritic
Season 2 - 38% metacritic




Definitely moved to the bottom of my pile.