Horizon for me is a more complete package than all the others so I give Aloy the crown.
Top notch graphics, gameplay, story, mission and combat variety.
Ghost of Tsushima is my favorite story theme but lacks in mission variety.
Bloodborne has no (apparent) story and for me, it’s a game that suits a limited player base.
Spider-man is flames but unfortunately it’s littered with poorly implemented stealth missions that make the pacing drag a bit. I’d say it’s neck and neck with Horizon though.
I haven’t played a second of Days Gone and don’t really have an interest in it.