TSC Match Ratings #1 NXT Takeover : New York

Dylmatic

All Star
Joined
Jul 6, 2012
Messages
3,273
Reputation
1,288
Daps
12,453
Reppin
France
Just got this idea.
The concept is to rate all the matches of a show and after everyone has voted, i'll make a ranking of the matches with their average scores.

Then at the end of the year we'll see what are the best rated matches here.

I feel like doing this for every WWE PPV and NXT Takeover if the first ones are successful.

So the first show is NXT Takeover : New York - April 5th 2019, here's the card :

War Raiders vs Aleister Black and Ricochet
Matt Riddle vs Velveteen Dream
WALTER vs Pete Dunne
Shayna Baszler vs Bianca Belair vs Kairi Sane vs Io Shirai
Adam Cole vs Johnny Gargano

You rate every match out of five, like the star ratings which is the most common in wrestling.

You have one week to cast your votes then i'll give the results.
 

Dylmatic

All Star
Joined
Jul 6, 2012
Messages
3,273
Reputation
1,288
Daps
12,453
Reppin
France
War Raiders vs Aleister Black and Ricochet : ****3/4
Matt Riddle vs Velveteen Dream : ****1/2
WALTER vs Pete Dunne : ****3/4
Shayna Baszler (c) vs Bianca Belair vs Kairi Sane vs Io Shirai : ****
Adam Cole vs Johnny Gargano : *****
 
Last edited:

Sypress

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
12,032
Reputation
3,501
Daps
37,898
War Raiders vs Aleister Black and Ricochet 5
Matt Riddle vs Velveteen Dream 4.5
WALTER vs Pete Dunne 5
Shayna Baszler vs Bianca Belair vs Kairi Sane vs Io Shirai 4
Adam Cole vs Johnny Gargano 4.5

Excellent show :blessed:
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
73,308
Reputation
5,752
Daps
174,629
WAR Raiders vs Ricochet/Aleister Black

4 stars


Dream vs Riddle

3 stars

Dunne vs WALTER

3 stars

Women's Fatal 4way

2 stars

Gargano vs Cole

3 stars

Im gonna be a harsh critic and great idea. Hope it pops off
:salute:
 

Yayo Toure

Mighty Man City
Supporter
Joined
May 23, 2012
Messages
10,948
Reputation
786
Daps
22,585
The only wack match was the women's match.

I been #NWG since August so I have no idea who the war raiders were, and how they were different from brothers of destruction, AOP, but their moveset set them apart. Solid 4/5.

Dream and Riddle was good, but predictable. They really let Riddle get too much offense in, so you know he had 0% chance of winning. Dream is always entertaining though, 4/5.

Walter VS Dunne was a good slugfest. Respect Dunnes work rate but have never been a huge fan. 4/5.

The women's match. Ehhhh. It was OK. 2.5/5.

Cole VS Gargano - 4.5/5. I'm still a bit divided about Undisputed Era interfering with the match, given how when Cole entered he walked off in a manner to suggest he'd be handling this fight alone, so their interference and his eventual loss sorta affects his character. Good match overall though.

Once again NXT will be the highlight of the weekend.
 

The Intergalactic Koala

Reporting for Duty
Supporter
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
58,670
Reputation
20,561
Daps
241,022
Reppin
Koalabama and the Cosmos
War Raiders vs Aleister Black and Ricochet- 4/5: Dope opener despite the ultra flippy shyt, this match was pretty good for what it was
Matt Riddle vs Velveteen Dream-5/5: :wow:that's all I'm going to leave. A Dream match is a automatic 5 imo.
WALTER vs Pete Dunne 3.75/5: Like I expressed in the OT, if this match was a old school "Catch Can" wrestling match, it would have been better. Both dudes are obvious grapplers and not so much adaptive to the WWE style, so it was sort of a battle between pacing, grappling, and keeping the fans interested.
Shayna Baszler vs Bianca Belair vs Kairi Sane vs Io Shirai: 2.75/5- This should have been a ladder match or some sort of gimmick because the pacing was all over the place, Shayna is a lazy fukking worker, Bianca is :lawd:, Kairi is good at what she does, and Io really can't adapt to the WWE style, so it became a big clusterfukk for the wrong reasons.
Adam Cole vs Johnny Gargano <--fukk this overbooked smark catering hogwash of a match:camby:

Its like this, NXT really starting to show it's flaws lately and the main event alone tops the cake. Maybe I'm too old school to this new age booking, but man :francis:, have some sort of rhyme and reason with these matches. Overall, the event itself could had been better. Compared to some of the "Mania week" material, sadly this really didn't do it for me this year which sucks because Takeovers>>>>>
 

Mr. Manhattan

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
17,063
Reputation
2,534
Daps
50,084
Reppin
NYC
from a live crowd perspective

War Raiders vs Richochet and Black - 4.5 Stars

Dream vs Riddle - 4.5 Stars

Dunne vs Walter - 4 stars

Fatal Four Way Woman's match 3.5 stars

Gargano vs Cole 4.5 Stars

my first takeover show live and it was awesome.
 

KevCo

Bond's gun spoke once....
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
9,199
Reputation
-9
Daps
15,001
Reppin
The Weird Side
War Raiders vs Aleister Black and Ricochet-3.5 stars
Matt Riddle vs Velveteen Dream-3.5 stars
WALTER vs Pete Dunne-3 stars
Shayna Baszler vs Bianca Belair vs Kairi Sane vs Io Shirai-3 stars
Adam Cole vs Johnny Gargano-4 stars

I figured Gargano would look strong but like someone mentioned, him literally kicking out of everything kinda took me out at points. Esp with the ref bump..ref shoulda been out for a few minutes then should have done a slow count with JG kicking out at 2 3/4... but solid show and very enjoyable.
 

Yayo Toure

Mighty Man City
Supporter
Joined
May 23, 2012
Messages
10,948
Reputation
786
Daps
22,585
from a live crowd perspective

War Raiders vs Richochet and Black - 4.5 Stars

Dream vs Riddle - 4.5 Stars

Dunne vs Walter - 4 stars

Fatal Four Way Woman's match 3.5 stars

Gargano vs Cole 4.5 Stars

my first takeover show live and it was awesome.

how did it smell in there?
 
Top