I think it is now obvious that winning the EPL and competing against Europe's best are night and day these days. Pick a world XI and you would struggle to fit in one EPL player there, even listing the top 10 players there will be a similar issue. Chelsea was playing one game a week throughout the season, wait till they are on a Wed-Sunday or Tue-Saturday schedule and the fixtures pile up. This is where the squad is important and it is also where Bayern's weakness is, if Lewandowski gets injured they are down to Muller(not a 9) and other inferior players. Spurs embarrassed themselves last season and they were playing at Wembley too, their problem with the squad is also apparent. Yaya is not enough in a semi-final against Real or even PSG at this rate. High pressing is also high risk and it can be easily exposed once a team beats the first wave of pressure. City has the squad but they need the balance , Gundogan and Yaya at this stage is not enough but they have enough going forward to get through to the knockout. The defense has mildly improved , not convinced Stones won't repeat his horrendous mistakes. Heynckes was peak Bayern, they had a better set up and could play with or without possession. Schweinsteiger and Martinez dominated that Barca midfield and they had Mandzukic for his workrate and the Alaba/Ribery and Robben/Lahm wing. Technically it was the best they ever played IMO. Pep threw that out for possession when teams had moved on to fewer passes and faster transition. They lost to Barca in 2015 because the front 3 of Barca was playing out of their minds, Messi was playing like a hybrid 10, false 9 and winger all wrapped into one. Pep had to use an injured Lewandowski I recall partly because squad depth was missing. Watch how Messi completely manhandled City in 2015 and then having Neymar and Suarez in their best form.
I don't think we are disagreeing up until the Heynckes' Bayern part since I didn't say the english teams are contenders so there ain't much to comment. I think CL games on the calendar don't make as much difference as people claim, it's usually an excuse for those who often lose the league because they shyt the bed against shytty teams, a.k.a Arsenal, but I'll leave it at that so the post doesn't get too big.
It's hard to argue opinion but I argue to this day that Pep's Bayern, barring injuries, were a more dominant team. The way they dominated the league wasn't even fun to watch, yeah Heynckes reached two champions league finals but he didn't have the same injury problems, specially with Robben and Riberry, his two best players. Aside from the Real Madrid games where Pep got it totally wrong and he even admited it, the way they lost both semis were heartbreaking to watch, against Barcelona they didn't have Alaba, Robben and Ribery and managed to win at home after making the game competitive in the first leg up until the point when Messi decided to be Messi, he even got his tactics wrong going with 3 at the back, I remember Barcelona was killing them on counters and he had to switch to 4 with like 10 minutes into the game, he also had no wingers that game, which is the #1 focal point of his system. Against Atletico they kind of got robbed and honestly they just had bad luck, his tactics were on point and the game at the Allianz Arena was as one-sided as can be, that year they were not very good on the road in the CL, for some reason, but everyone knew they would massacre any team at home and they did.
When that Heynckes team played Barcelona, Messi had a hamstring injury in the first leg and he didn't even play in the second game. Sanchez , Puyol , Mascherano , Busquets and Alba didn't play either
Both were great though, but I just feel like Pep had terrible luck and a much better domestic record, Klopp dominated Heynckes in 2011/12, he went trophyless that season, if it wasn't for Robben bailing them out in the last minute in that CL final, I don't think it would be a discussion to this day.
But PSG who still has the coach who choked a 4-0 lead is better? You're just assuming that they will be injured, but even so they are probably the only team that has depth comparable to real madrid. None of those teams that you mentioned are better than Bayern. Atletico can't keep up with Bayern and Juventus got exposed in the finals. In all honesty the real CL finals took place in the QF between Real and Bayern.
It's too soon to tell if any of the PL teams on are the level of Atletico or PSG, let alone Bayern.
The same coach who gave Barcelona the business in the first leg too. A 6-1 will never be mainly the coach's fault, the players choked it because they thought it was over after Cavani's goal, it's like the 7-1, Barcelona would never pull that off again even if they played 100 times, shyt happens, for a team as good as PSG, even if the coach fukks up the tactics, there's no explanation to conceding 6 to anybody, and the refs heavily helped Barcelona in that game.
Bayern have "depth" but they are not as good tactically as before and they are rarely fully fit, it doesn't matter how many players they have on the bench, you could argue Barcelona didn't have much depth in 2015 and they won the treble, Atletico haven't had that much depth ever since they became good again and they have been dominant.
Neuer, Thiago, Javi Martínez, James, Boateng & Bernat already injuried at the beginning of the season, Robben coming back from an injury today and is historically injury prone, same for Ribery, maybe you just don't watch them enough to think I'm assuming shyt.
Atletico can't keep up with Bayern and Juventus got exposed in the finals. In all honesty the real CL finals took place in the QF between Real and Bayern.
Have you actually been watching Bayern? Anyone can see that they are much worse than with Pep, they have no identity anymore, no gameplan, their game is actually ugly to watch, specially if you compare it to how they have been player for the last, at least 5 years. Leverkusen gave them a run for their money in the second half today but they just couldn't finish, a better team would've probably won that game.
You wanna bet that either United, Chelsea or City are going further than Bayern this season?