The most overhyped "should've been great" guy(s) in your opinion....

[Nintendough]

Sean O'Haire.....A couple of promos really had yall ready to buy stock in this?









It was all fine and dandy until it was time to watch his matches.

 

[Wcthesecret]

Sean O'Haire.....A couple of promos really had yall ready to buy stock in this?




Sean O'haire vignette on drugs - YouTube




It was all fine and dandy until it was time to watch his matches.

I'm sold on him, should've been better

 

[Tide Run This]

Carlito

 

[Wcthesecret]

Chavo Guerrero if he was ever.

 

[ML29]

Nathan Jones. his introduction videos were amazing but it was all down hill when he actually had to perform in front of actual audiences smh.

 

[Momentum]

 

[Tommy Fits]

Carlito

I thought Carlito was going to be the next big star and thought he had that "it" factor. Instead the highlight of his career was chasing a midget into a wall.

 

[Riley Escobar]

Controversial choice, but:

Gimmick was piff, promos were piff, whole character was piff...but goddamn his matches were terrible

 

[Toe Jay Simpson]

I thought Carlito was going to be the next big star and thought he had that "it" factor. Instead the highlight of his career was chasing a midget into a wall.

Carlito used to wrestle in slow motion

 

[Nintendough]

Wait, brehs actually thought Miz was going to be great?

 

[I-Hate-You]

I agree with Hassan. The way wrestling fans speak about him is hilarious to me.

Hulk run-in at Mania was still GOAT though

 

[Jamal514]

Bobby Lashley, the guys voice when cutting promos was cringeworthy.

 

[RammerJammer]

Wade Barrett

 

[SanfordMan75]

Controversial choice, but:

Gimmick was piff, promos were piff, whole character was piff...but goddamn his matches were terrible

 

[Nintendough]

Wade Barrett

Its amazing how much potential he showed when he was in Nexus. His heel swagger was on another level. Now he just seems like another midcarder.