Update on mine: the $48.88 charge is something different - this is an Amazon return that has been charged again. Yaaaaaay, now I get to go through THIS shyt again. (I had a return that I had to fight for nearly a year; they would just cut my account off at random.) Complained to Amazon and they gave me a $10 credit. So now, b/t a $5 gift card I had, the %20 off for Prime and this $10 credit, my game is roughly $36.
But I broke down and ordered it from Best Buy for pickup anyway. Hopefully there's no "special-to-Best-Buy-only" sticker on it, b/c as soon as I get the Amazon copy, it's going straight back to BB unopened. There's no way I'm going to waste a perfectly good weekend doing nothing but reading reviews!