The Gladiator Class: a deeper look at social economic class and athletes

Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
1,886
Reputation
-20
Daps
1,638
Over the last couple of weeks I have been reflecting on something that, though it has been an issue in MMA and a lesser extent boxing, it has never been something I cared much about. The issue I am talking about has affected my favorite baseball team, the San Francisco Giants. Melky Caberra, who the fan base had lovingly called the "Melk Man," was found to have been doping. In hindsight, he probably doped last year in Kansas City to prolong his career. When I first heard about Melky I felt cheated, hurt, and betrayed. It was almost like when Juan Uribe went to the miserable colors of blue after the Giants won the World Series.

Then I began to think look back over my years watching baseball and I thought that maybe I noticed a kind of pattern. I wonder if there are some class issues associated with juicing. Do players who come from under class or even lower middle class backgrounds tend to feel more pressure to perform in Triple A? These class issues may also, in some cases be linked to race as well. As a white male I know of what I speak. I understand white privilege, for the most part, because every day I benefit from it. See, I can fail with a certain amount of security in knowing my family is there to catch me. I can drive my car anywhere without being bothered and I can walk around in a store without the security guard following me. I know plenty of white players have juiced over time, but I wonder how the pressure of creating a life out of baseball without any safety net can impact the decisions a guy might make in order to have success.

So, what does this have to do with boxing? Jon Jones who we have beat to death over the course of minutes, hours, days, turned down a fight on 8 days notice resulting in the card, UFC 151, being cancelled. We can argue about the morality of Jones not thinking of others who lost a lot of money in the process. Dana White would have made a stronger card and the decision Jones made might not have villianized him to a whole fan base that already has trouble embracing diversity.

I am not really interested in going into that since I have written two other pieces on the subject [Jones & UFC 151] and it is a mute point. I bring this up because a financial burden and/or the strain of no hope seems to have created a gladiator class in our society. What is the gladiator class? The gladiator class is the men and women who are serving overseas in the line of fire, doing multiple tours of duty, the majority of whom are not from elite families. The gladiator class is the farm system baseball players in baseball like Melky, who take "juice" just to stay relevant in the sport to avoid the alternative. The gladiator class, in the most classic sense, is represented by Arturo Gotti and Johnny Tapia, men who were not just gladiators in the ring, but lived as such outside, partially explaining their shortened lives.

As the days go by, I have found one thing to be true. Jon Jones is not from the gladiator class, he is an athlete. Is there anything wrong with that? No, but the UFC seems to feel that if you are not willing to fight on the drop of the dime for the mishandled undercards, which are slowly becoming worse than most boxing PPV. Jones was selfish, but maybe he truly isn't a fighter - just someone to whom the sport came easy and if he cannot create a tactical game plan, he feels as naked in the cage.



Another comparison I thought of was Victor Ortiz who since Josesito Lopez broke his jaw and quit on the stool and has been labeled a quitter. I have often wondered if Ortiz even enjoyed boxing, if it was nothing more than a job to him, and something that he was very good at. With Ortiz when any resistance is shown he seems to fold and in his last fight he was even berated by his trainer, Robert Garcia, for quitting. Should we critique these fighters based on the fact that they are not able to show toughness of Ali's, LaMottas, Ray Robinsons, or should we celebrate their greatness as fighters who are able to fight on a moment’s notice or fight through the tough times.

So, what I wish to leave you with is one thing for every Jon Jones who thinks that guy on the card will get cut after he loses his next fight, but keeps fighting in terribly sanctioned events for no other reason than to avoid what he has to go home to. The guys who were all-state baseball players in high school, and college. Then they find themselves as nothing more than role players on a Triple A team competing against players who obviously seem to have done something to their bodies to emulate the physiques of Greek Gods. This not a letter of sympathy or excuse for any of those who use steroids, this is more of a reflection about how people can justify what they do. Much like America today, we have created an unspoken caste system and at the bottom of the pole is the gladiator class who is expected to entertain, fight our wars and be voiceless. Yet, when those who come from the gladiator class take short cuts we look at them as though they have no moral standard. Just some food for thought.
 

Jutt

All Star
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
6,482
Reputation
790
Daps
8,500
Reppin
Boston
You see this stigma more in MMA...i think a lot of it has to do with MMAs roots. No holds barred and such. You see people talking about it all the time, but the fact of the matter the sport had to evolve into such, or else we'd never see it. People tend to forget that the gory glory of the OG UFC lost its luster after awhile, thats when Uncle Dana stepped in and transformed it, for better or worse, depending on how you view it. Times have changed like you said, guys fight because they are good at it, not because the HAVE to.




Good read as usual bro.

Edit: I'll also add to the fact that Jones is a super athletic kid who picked up fighting on a whim and been tearing shyt up ever since, even though hes one of the hardest workers in the biz, the 'casual' fanbase doesnt see that. Another reason he's not as liked
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
1,886
Reputation
-20
Daps
1,638
You see this stigma more in MMA...i think a lot of it has to do with MMAs roots. No holds barred and such. You see people talking about it all the time, but the fact of the matter the sport had to evolve into such, or else we'd never see it. People tend to forget that the gory glory of the OG UFC lost its luster after awhile, thats when Uncle Dana stepped in and transformed it, for better or worse, depending on how you view it. Times have changed like you said, guys fight because they are good at it, not because the HAVE to.

Good read as usual bro.

It is just something that is interesting and for the interest of time, compare Jones to Aldo and think about just the different types of cultural influence as well as mindset to fighting, nearly night and day - yet both are as feared as the sport has seen in their weight class
 

Jutt

All Star
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
6,482
Reputation
790
Daps
8,500
Reppin
Boston
It is just something that is interesting and for the interest of time, compare Jones to Aldo and think about just the different types of cultural influence as well as mindset to fighting, nearly night and day - yet both are as feared as the sport has seen in their weight class

Thats more of a cultural thing if anything, Brazilians are feared/reveared moreso in this sport more than anyone for the most part, except for Vinny Maghales(:russ:)

But because Jose was dirt poor helps him become more liked. This is especially the case with Rousimar Pahlares. Dudes got a vicious scar from farming, and is one of the most likeable guys in the sport. :yeshrug:
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
1,886
Reputation
-20
Daps
1,638
Thats more of a cultural thing if anything, Brazilians are feared/reveared moreso in this sport more than anyone for the most part, except for Vinny Maghales(:russ:)

But because Jose was dirt poor helps him become more liked. This is especially the case with Rousimar Pahlares. Dudes got a vicious scar from farming, and is one of the most likeable guys in the sport. :yeshrug:

I guess what I was saying was that when you get a guy from a very poor country with little to no hope of a "normal" stable life and they get a chance to excel that they have more of a gladiator attitude to get to that point at any cost.

When a middle class fighter may be more cerebral and think through things and view cheating or putting it all on the line as a moral issue
 

Jutt

All Star
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
6,482
Reputation
790
Daps
8,500
Reppin
Boston
I guess what I was saying was that when you get a guy from a very poor country with little to no hope of a "normal" stable life and they get a chance to excel that they have more of a gladiator attitude to get to that point at any cost.

When a middle class fighter may be more cerebral and think through things and view cheating or putting it all on the line as a moral issue

Eh, i see what youre saying but there are some dudes that have had rough upbringing that are soft as fukk, and some guys are tough.

Really depends on the person, but guys that are born in 3rd world countries tend to have a bigger drive, because its not only their livelyhood, but there are probably dozens of people at home depending on them.
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
1,886
Reputation
-20
Daps
1,638
Eh, i see what youre saying but there are some dudes that have had rough upbringing that are soft as fukk, and some guys are tough.

Really depends on the person, but guys that are born in 3rd world countries tend to have a bigger drive, because its not only their livelyhood, but there are probably dozens of people at home depending on them.
why you got to call out Rumble Johnson like that
 
Top