https://kotaku.com/the-collapse-of-viscerals-ambitious-star-wars-game-1819916152
Article too long to copy /paste
Article too long to copy /paste
The Collapse Of Visceral's Star Wars Game
- Thread starter Dominic Brehetto
- Start date
Reading through this it's no shock EA is the culprit.
So many choice paragraphs
Visceral asked all of its employees to help out on the cop game. Switching from third-person action-adventure games to a first-person shooter had been a rough adjustment for many people at Visceral, sources said, and a lot of them still didn’t actually want to make Hardline. Morale had sunk at the studio by then, and Visceral was already losing key artists and engineers who weren’t interested in working on the game. “EA does internal health surveys,” said one person who worked on the game. “Throughout most of Hardline’s production, Visceral had the worst team health survey at EA, for like two years running.”
Hennig also wasn’t used to working with a corporation like Electronic Arts. Despite being owned by electronics giant Sony, Naughty Dog had been able to operate autonomously, in large part because they were widely perceived as the corporation’s prestige video game studio. At EA, however, things were different. “She was giving these massive presentations on the story, themes,” said one person who worked on Ragtag. “EA executives are like, ‘FIFA Ultimate Team makes a billion dollars a year.’ Where’s your version of that?”
And EA had Amy open a second studio with the sole purpose of helping make the game and decided to have them work in battlefront 2 instead.
So many choice paragraphs
Visceral asked all of its employees to help out on the cop game. Switching from third-person action-adventure games to a first-person shooter had been a rough adjustment for many people at Visceral, sources said, and a lot of them still didn’t actually want to make Hardline. Morale had sunk at the studio by then, and Visceral was already losing key artists and engineers who weren’t interested in working on the game. “EA does internal health surveys,” said one person who worked on the game. “Throughout most of Hardline’s production, Visceral had the worst team health survey at EA, for like two years running.”
Hennig also wasn’t used to working with a corporation like Electronic Arts. Despite being owned by electronics giant Sony, Naughty Dog had been able to operate autonomously, in large part because they were widely perceived as the corporation’s prestige video game studio. At EA, however, things were different. “She was giving these massive presentations on the story, themes,” said one person who worked on Ragtag. “EA executives are like, ‘FIFA Ultimate Team makes a billion dollars a year.’ Where’s your version of that?”
And EA had Amy open a second studio with the sole purpose of helping make the game and decided to have them work in battlefront 2 instead.
Last edited:
TheNatureBoy
Veteran
Great article, really insightful stuff as to what went wrong and game development in general 
Some of the concepts they came up with seemed really ambitious, but would have been
if they could have pulled them off.
A shame history repeated itself again with this game and 1313. We may never get a fully fledged single player adventure game
Some of the concepts they came up with seemed really ambitious, but would have been
if they could have pulled them off.A shame history repeated itself again with this game and 1313. We may never get a fully fledged single player adventure game
Mighty Mike
SOHH veteran
This is one of the best journalism pieces on gaming I've ever read.
Read his book, blood sweat and pixels. It's basically an entire book like this. Like 10 or so different games.