Retro collectors, whats your opinion of Reproductions? *Kinda long OP*

Tenchi Ryu

Ashtray B!tch
Joined
Nov 17, 2014
Messages
88,502
Reputation
25,450
Daps
401,274
Reppin
Chicago - SouthSide - Wild 100s
For those not aware, since the cost of limited classic games have gone up, a method that's getting more and more popular is buying reproduction games, which is basically a burned disc or replicated cartridge that has had extensive printing to ensure it looks as close to the original as possible. For an example, at the beginning of 2018, I bought a reproduction jewel case for Marvel Vs Capcom 1, a game I've always had but just the disc, when I was younger I bought the disc from FuncoLand by itself and as a collector now I wanted to complete the whole thing, so instead of buying the whole thing on ebay for 50+ dollars, I bought a repro case for 10 that also included a reproduced manual

DdXchvzWAAIwfQF.jpg


DdXchvoW4AEb1kd.jpg


DdXchv5XkAAx4mk.jpg



As of this post, about 1 hour ago I bought a complete reproduction of Project Justice that includes everything for 19.99

20180429022827_1024x1024@2x.jpg


20180429022833_1024x1024@2x.jpg
20180429022856HDR_1024x1024@2x.jpg


Now as stated above, this is straight up a burned disc that has artwork printed to make it look as close to authentic as possible. Now there's two ways this can be seen being positive or negative.

For positive reasons, I'm getting a playable copy of Project Justice that just cost me about 100 dollars less than the price its going on average on ebay right now. Luckily dreamcast itself dont have too many games like this where Sega Saturn is a whole different story...You'll be lucky to find a copy of burning rangers for less than 250 dollars on ebay. Meanwhile once again, you can get a repro copy for 20 bucks that looks like this

20180112143618HDR_1024x1024@2x.jpg

20180112143625HDR_1024x1024@2x.jpg

20180112143632_1024x1024@2x.jpg



So where the negative group lies is that they fear these can infiltrate the market and be duped as real copies, obviously someone who's not keen to knowing how to spot authentic from fake can wind up spending 300 dollars on something that was made for just 20. Certain groups in the collecting community looks down at reproductions for this reason.


So coli retro brehs, do you have a moral disagreement with buying repros?
 

Kamikaze Revy

Bwana ni mwokozi wangu
Supporter
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
29,692
Reputation
9,366
Daps
76,045
Reppin
Outer Heaven
Depends how rare the game is and how much I care about it. :patrice:
I have most of what I would want, but I suppose if the right game came along I would pay $100-$125 max for it. It would have to be something pretty special to me though and I would have to be confident that it's 100% original.
For something super rare that's going for more than that, I wouldn't mind a reproduced copy like that the ones you have in the OP.
Those seem pretty well done and wouldn't bother me so much.
 

AnotherRoute

Just another post by
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
6,089
Reputation
990
Daps
18,270
Reppin
BR..O..OK...LYN
For me it lies on what’s your purpose of collecting. Is it full blown collect and sell or collect and play. Collect and play I am all for reproduction I am ok for reproduction. I also look at it as a way to persevere old school gaming thats just me though.

I fall in the collect and play side I have a few things I will not touch .
 

Tenchi Ryu

Ashtray B!tch
Joined
Nov 17, 2014
Messages
88,502
Reputation
25,450
Daps
401,274
Reppin
Chicago - SouthSide - Wild 100s
For me it lies on what’s your purpose of collecting. Is it full blown collect and sell or collect and play. Collect and play I am all for reproduction I am ok for reproduction. I also look at it as a way to persevere old school gaming thats just me though.

I fall in the collect and play side I have a few things I will not touch .
Yea that's how I look at it. Especially with some of these scratched up disc I have. The repros give them a chance to get a break being 20 years old now.
 

Ciggavelli

|∞||∞||∞||∞|
Supporter
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
27,999
Reputation
6,572
Daps
57,324
Reppin
Houston
:ld:

I personally like to have the actual games, but that’s just for collecting. I have several real copies of rare Saturn games (Panzer Dragoon Saga, Shining Force, Christmas Nights, etc), but I don’t even own a Saturn anymore. I even got some NES games with the original boxes (kinda beat up though, but real).

If I was actually playing the games and just wanted to add to the packaging, reproductions make sense.

For collecting, nah :hubie:
 

NZA

LOL
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
21,738
Reputation
4,075
Daps
55,721
Reppin
Run Thru U Like Skattebo
no repro for me. if i cant have the real thing then i would settle for a rom. im too much of a collector to have some bootleg, even if well put together. i also dont like the possibility that indie game shops and ebay sellers can trick somebody with these things
 
Top