Ranking Every Undertaker Wrestlemania Match

[Nostalgic]

 

[Mʀ2ᴋDᴇᴇᴢ]

Damn I already forgot Cena faced off against him in a Mania match


Saw that come up and had to think like damn

 

[FunkDoc1112]

How I have it:
A Tier (4.5-5)
25
26
28
23
B Tier (3.75-4)
17
29
24
21
27
18
C Tier (3-3.5)
12
14
22
31
32
D Tier (2-2.5)
19
20
33
8
7
Tier
11

30
9
15

Seven and Eight were basically squash matches so I can't put them in the bottom.

 

[Bob Loblaw]

1apunk
1bhbk

 

[Mike the Executioner]

How I have it:
A Tier (4.5-5)
25
26
28
23
B Tier (3.75-4)
17
29
24
21
27
18
C Tier (3-3.5)
12
14
22
31
32
D Tier (2-2.5)
19
20
33
8
7
Tier
11

30
9
15

Seven and Eight were basically squash matches so I can't put them in the bottom.

I would switch 30 and 33. The Lesnar match could have been a lot better if Undertaker didn't get that concussion, and the streak ending will always give the match a historical significance that many of the other matches don't have.

The Reigns match, on the other hand, was one of the worst matches I've ever seen and it was embarrassing to see Undertaker be so .

 

[thaKEAF]

Yeah the Roman match was awful.

 

[thaKEAF]

He is wilding with the AJ “match” being that high.

 

[Playaz Eyez]

The Reigns match was horrific.

The Punk one should be in the first tier. My most watched WM match from Taker.

 

[Malik1time]

Undertaker vs Batista was great…more so the entire rivalry during 2007
Remember this promo
Goosebump’s
2007 was a good year

 

[Nostalgic]

WM27 is waaaaaay to damn high on his list.

That match was nothing but a bunch of finishers from Undertaker and HHH.

 

[Ripp]

1apunk
1bhbk

You gotta be a cm punk fan.... I remember that match the least out of all of takers matches.

1. hbk retirement match
2. hbk 1st match
3. the first Kane match
4. randy orton
5 is the one where triple h put him on the stretcher (the year before the end of an era match)

 

[Bob Loblaw]

You gotta be a cm punk fan.... I remember that match the least out of all of takers matches.

1. hbk retirement match
2. hbk 1st match
3. the first Kane match
4. randy orton
5 is the one where triple h put him on the stretcher (the year before the end of an era match)

Orton match was good
All of hhh WM matches against taker were mid the ones after hbk fought him were copy and pAst

 

[Ripp]

Orton match was good
All of hhh WM matches against taker were mid the ones after hbk fought him were copy and pAst

I liked the very next one where HHH tried to beat taker in honor of HBK. Story telling was fire and HHH took taker to the limit. Me and my sister were at a lounge/bar for that mania and the atmosphere in the room was crazy. We actually thought HHH could pull it off. He beat the shyt out of taker to the point where taker had beat him with a hells gate because he didn't have the strength to stand up let alone tombstone him. And watching Taker being taken out on a stretcher was crazy.. imo this match was actually the precursor to the ending of the streak and made people question "how many more does he have in him?" I had never seen Taker more humanized than the finish of that match

I probably like this match because I usually watch mania at home so being in a crowd situation gave it a special feel lol. The end of an era hell in a cell was just overkill

 

[Dog Based Gremlin]

Going to try to do this in one take without much thinking since I'm sleepy but...

1. Kane (1998/wm 14)
   
2. HBK (2010/wm 25)
   
3. HBK (2011/wm 26)
4. Edge (2008/wm 24)
5. Lesnar (2014/wm 30)
6. HHH (all 3 matches are ranked here)
7. CM Punk (2013/wm 29)