rank aftermath debuts . sslp vs get rich or die tryin vs documentary vs good kidMcity

[tonyclifton]

i gotta revisit sslp and get rich first

 

[BlackZilla]

Commercially GRODT > SSLP > GKMC

Musically (Themes, Cohesiveness) SSLP <= GKMC > GRODT

Musically (The number of songs that I liked a lot on each album) GRODT > GKMC > SSLP

 

[tonyclifton]

Commercially GRODT > SSLP > GKMC

Musically (Themes, Cohesiveness) SSLP >= GKMC > GRODT

Musically (The number of songs that I liked a lot on each album) GRODT > GKMC > SSLP

forgot games debut just added it

 

[Busby]

Hmmm good question...

1. The Documentary
2. Get Rich Or Die Tryin
3. good kid, m.A.A.d city
4. Slim Shady LP

 

[tonyclifton]

notice how they are all considered classics ( gkmc pending but its looking that way)


aftermath

 

[Ashtrey]

The Documentary = Good Kid, Maad City

I don't care about the others.

 

[fundz]

I fukk w/ Game but The Documentary does not belong in this convo...

Slim Shady LP/Good Kid tied for first spot
GRODT coming in third


































The Documentary (dead last)

 

[45123]

All of those albums barring GKMC have impacted the culture way beyond what Kendrick could do x10 in 2 weeks. The significance of those 3 albums alone makes it incomparable to good kid, mAAd city. Not saying GKMC isn't as good, but those albums influenced a whole genre for years, this shyt ain't even been out for a month.

 

[Busby]

notice how they are all considered classics ( gkmc pending but its looking that way)


aftermath

Aftermath..and ain't NOTHING after that!