Need help wth a trade.

[Nick Barnes]

I have Vick, Ryan Mathews, Fitz and Petigrew. this guy is willing to trade me Big Ben, Roddy White, Doug Martin and Jimmy Graham for them.

what you guys think? should i do it?

 

[Nick Barnes]

 

[South Paw]

PPR?

 

[Nick Barnes]

PPR?

half point per reception.

 

[Listen]

Lemme help you a bit breh:

QB - Mike Vick (Injury Risk)
3619 22 13 682 5

vs.

QB - Big Ben
4022 25 14 112 1

Edge: Vick


RB - Ryan Mathews (Injury risk)
1159 8 52 443 1

VS.
RB - Doug Martin
935 6 32 265 1

Edge: Ryan Matthews

WR - Larry Fitzgerald
87/1305/8

vs.

WR - Roddy White
96/1241/9


Edge: WASH

TE - Brandon Petigrew
70/713/5

VS.

TE - Jimmy Graham
90/1209/11

Edge: Jimmy


I mean, from a position to position match up, it's not really a winner for you.

From a total points perscpetive...I dunno. Grahamn should score you 50-70 more points than Pettigrew, Roddy and Fitz should be close. Matthews 'if he comes back and stays healthy' shuld score more than Martin and I imagine the same thing for Vick, as long as hes healthy.

Tough call. but Vick and Matthews are risk reward players, while Doug Martin is a rookie. Roddy and Jimmy are going to live up to their billing and should be sure things, so, tough.

 

[Absolut]

i wouldnt do it. vick/matthews/fitz/pettigrew is rather easily the better 4 some

 

[Heelmatic]

i wouldnt do it. vick/matthews/fitz/pettigrew is rather easily the better 4 some

I agree with this. I wouldn't do it either. You have the better players.

 

[NamelessPimp]

I like your players as well. Although injury risks, Mathews injury won't impact his running ability. I believe Fitz is a much better WR than White too. The only thing you'd really be gaining is points at the TE position.

 

[Nick Barnes]

Ok thanks, I won't do it.

Appreciate the help.

 

[RJY33]

Think about his motivation for doing it also. No smart player makes 1-1 position trades to benefit another team. If you dont mind the Matthews and Vick injury risk then keep your guys. Vick's upside>>>>Big Ben consistancy

 

[KiD WavE]

trade is fairly even ...cant really tell you if its worth it until the season is over ...just have to go with your gut