Need help with this trade

[#StarkSet]

I was Offered Gronk/ Andre johnson/ Newton for Nelson/ Brees/ Beanie

should I do it?

newton is a risk while brees is guaranteed points

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

nikka is u crazy?

 

[DredScott]

I was Offered Gronk/ Andre johnson/ Newton for Nelson/ Brees/ Beanie

should I do it?

newton is a risk while brees is guaranteed points

unless you're getting a top tier RB like mccoy/rice/foster or even murray or forte, this trade is an L for you.

beanie wells is horrible and prolly won't even be the starter by mid-season either due to injury or ineffectiveness.

in order to see how bad this trade is though, i need to know what is your current fantasy roster and what is his.

but just going off this info i'd decline the trade and tell him he needs to give you a guaranteed starting RB in order to make this trade fair.


EDIT - that's what i get for reading the The Coli after taking a long nap.

i thought you were trading cam/gronk and andre for brees and them, not getting offered those players. in that case, do it before that idiot realizes how lopsided the trade is.

 

[Marty Funkhouser]

Do it. Cam may struggle but he'll put up fantasy points regardless because of his ability to run. Even if Brees is better the gain from the other 2 should more than make up for the difference. Wells is a scrub & It'll be tough for Nelson to repeat his year from last year.