Metacritic Superhero film rankings

[Whitty Hutton]

Somebody at imdb compiled this list
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1843866/board/thread/228141537
1. Superman II - 87/100 - B+
2. Superman: The Movie - 86/100 - B+
3. Spider-Man 2 - 83/100 - B-
4. The Dark Knight - 82/100 - B-
5. Iron Man - 79/100 - C+
6A. The Dark Knight Rises - 78/100 - C+
6B. Hellboy 2: The Golden Army - 78/100 - C+
7. Spider-Man - 73/100 - C-
8A. Superman Returns - 72/100 - C-
8B. Hellboy - 72/100 - C-
9A. Batman Begins - 70/100 - C-
9B. Captain America: The Winter Soldier - 70/100 - C-
10. The Avengers - 69/100 - D+
11. X2: X-Men United - 68/100 - D+
12A. Batman - 66/100 - D+
12B. Captain America: The First Avenger - 66/100 - D+
12C. The Amazing Spider-Man - 66/100 - D+
12D. Kick-Ass - 66/100 - D+
13A. X-Men: First Class - 65/100 - D
13B. Mystery Men - 65/100 - D
14A. Wanted - 64/100 - D-
14B. X-Men - 64/100 - D-
15A. Iron Man 3 - 62/100 - D-
15B. V for Vendetta - 62/100 - D-
16. The Incredible Hulk - 61/100 - D-
17. The Wolverine - 60/100 - D-
18A. Spider-Man 3 - 59/100 - F
18B. Dredd - 59/100 - F
19. X-Men 3: The Last Stand - 58/100 - F
20A. Iron Man 2 - 57/100 - F
20B. Thor - 57/100 - F
21. Watchmen - 56/100 - F
22. Man of Steel - 55/100 - F
23A. Thor: The Dark World - 54/100 - F-
23B. Hulk - 54/100 - F-
24. Blade 2 - 52/100 - F-
25. Batman Forever - 51/100 - F-
26. Constantine - 50/100 - F-
27A. Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer - 45/100 - FF
27B. Blade - 45/100 - FF
28A. Daredevil - 42/100 - FF-
28B. Superman III - 42/100 - FF-
29. Kick-Ass 2 - 41/100 - FF-
30A. Fantastic Four - 40/100 - FF-
30B. X-Men Origins: Wolverine - 40/100 - FF-
31A. Green Lantern - 39/100 - FFF
31B. The Green Hornet - 39/100 - FFF
32. Blade: Trinity - 38/100 - FFF
33. Ghost Rider - 35/100 - FFF
34. Spawn - 34/100 - FFF-
34B. Elektra - 34/100 - FFF-
35A. Jonah Hex - 33/100 - FFF-
35B. The Punisher - 33/100 - FFF-
36. Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance - 32/100 - FFF-
37A. The Punisher: War Zone - 30/100 - FFF-
37B. The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen - 30/100 - FFF-
37C. The Spirit - 30/100 - FFF-
38. Batman and Robin - 28/100 - FFFF
39. Catwoman - 27/100 - FFFF
40. Superman IV: The Quest For Peace - 22/100 - FFFF-


@ FFFF- ratings

 

[Swiggy]

Superman II over Superman The Movie???

Don't need to read no more

 

[Bender Rodriguez]

the top 3?

 

[b_low_brown]

the top 3?

We gonna act like Spider-Man 2 don't belong in the top 3?

 

[King Koopa]

The hell is up with all these random shytty comic book movie lists popping up?

Superman Returns in the top 10? And over Man of Steel

 

[Bender Rodriguez]

We gonna act like Spider-Man 2 don't belong in the top 3?

cause it doesn't belong there at all

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

38. Batman and Robin - 28/100 - FFFF
overrated

 

[NV-ME]

both hellboys above the avengers...

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

The hell is up with all these random shytty comic book movie lists popping up?

Superman Returns in the top 10? And over Man of Steel

Superman Returns wasn't better than man of Steel but it WAS a great movie, fun to watch, it FELT like a superman comic book, had a GOAT villian in Spacey's Luthor, and was ONLY hated by nerds after the movie was out...in the moment it was a smash success and people liked it.

It is shockingly (retroactively) underrated.

 

[2 Up 2 Down]

Dredd is too low and this should be Comic Book based films and not Superhero


no Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles or TMNT

 

[stepbackj34spud]

TDKR was awful.. stop reading after that.

 

[ORDER_66]

Wait a minute?!?!? Superman Returns is better than Cap2 the winter soldier?!? Even Man of Steel?!!?

 

[OmegaK2099]

Spiderman 2?

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

Wait a minute?!?!? Superman Returns is better than Cap2 the winter soldier?!? Even Man of Steel?!!?

...no...thats not what the list says

It says that at the time of review...as the film was being released...that many % of positive reviews were published from their chosen sources....nobody compared superman returns to movies that had not come out yet...nor were those movies actively compared to superman returns. Feel free to reaction gif this too though

 

[StraxStrax]

Nice seeing this classic so "high"