Is Tip one of The GOATS?

[King Karim]

7 albums, multi-multi millions sold, respected by peers and the hip hop community musically, longevity, talent, and a very very very strong discography.


Yes he is

 

[Mr. Manhattan]

yes and no

u figure that out

 

[DaveyDave]

NO

 

[RajWatts]

q-tip? absolutely

 

[King Karim]

q-tip? absolutely

No, and I don't think Qtip qualifies for this convo

 

[T'Kuvma Da Unforgettable]

yeah them ATCQ albums are classic

 

[DaveyDave]

No, and I don't think Qtip qualifies for this convo

with the exception of the number of albums (not sure how many Q Tip has off top of my head) then everything else you said applies to him as much as it does to TI. don't know what sales he has tho, but he has been involved in a lot of shyt

 

[Ian1362]

Tip isn't a GOAT skill rapper, but he's definitely in my top ten favorites. ATCQ were instrumental in cultivating my musical identity.

 

[zerozero]

q-tip? absolutely

 

[phatphuck]

tip? no

atcq as a group? yes

 

[King Karim]

with the exception of the number of albums (not sure how many Q Tip has off top of my head) then everything else you said applies to him as much as it does to TI. don't know what sales he has tho, but he has been involved in a lot of shyt

well let me bring some more clarity to the thread..my bad, thats on me. I mean solo greats. Yes, QTip w/o a shadow of a doubt is a Legend himself, however he only had like 2 solo's I think and I don't think many would debate that those 2 solo albums deserve to be mentioned in a solo artist convo about best ever(one of the best ever)

 

[dre]

In Atlanta and maybe the South yeah in general

 

[NSSVO]

Yea he once was the biggest star in rap. Held it down for a couple summers. I think he's up there.

 

[↓R↑LYB]

Don't know if he's the goat, but he's def one of my faves. Looks like I'll be copping trouble man when it drops too. Trap Back Jumpin is dope.

 

[TrapHouse Rock]

HALF YALL TALKIN BOUT TI, HALF YALL TALKIN BOUT TIP.