How would you rank Goldberg, Brock Lesnar, and Batista?

[ManBearPig]

The beast
The animal
The Streak

 

[MushroomX]

If the criteria is overall impact to the Wrestling product:

1. Lesnar
2. Goldberg
3. Batista

Lesnar gets tops because he won titles outside WWE, and won legit in MMA. If Goldberg did so he would be #1.

 

[ÆTHER]

I'm too young to remember Goldberg's WCW run but its easy to see that he was pretty much the blueprint for the other 2. Brock's first WWE run was genuinely special. If dude didn't leave so early he'd be on Top 10 of all time lists in my opinion. He could work any type of match with any guy. Cena's legacy would be wildly different too. Batista was cool too especially in 2010.

Based on what I've seen with my two eyes. I guess my order would be:

1. Brock
2. Batista
3. Goldberg

 

[thenatural]

1. Goldberg
2. Brock
3. Batista

 

[ManBearPig]

I'm too young to remember Goldberg's WCW run but its easy to see that he was pretty much the blueprint for the other 2. Brock's first WWE run was genuinely special. If dude didn't leave so early he'd be on Top 10 of all time lists in my opinion. He could work any type of match with any guy. Cena's legacy would be wildly different too. Batista was cool too especially in 2010.

Based on what I've seen with my two eyes. I guess my order would be:

1. Brock
2. Batista
3. Goldberg

Same here but the reason why Goldberg is last to me is because he has like 3 great matches

 

[Buggsy Mogues]

Goldberg

Brock








Batista

 

[Here Comes the Pain]

All three are GOAT tier.

Lesnar is the bigger crossover star tho.:Lesnarumad:

 

[ndthentherewasx]

1. Goldberg
2. Brock
3. Batista

 

[Lo-Co]

Brock
Batista
Goldberg

I grew up during the 03' Goldberg run. Explains why he's third.

 

[R=G]

Brock
Batista
Goldberg

I grew up during the 03' Goldberg run. Explains why he's third.

That's just WWE booking and Cripple H jealousy. Goldberg is one of the biggest stars in history. He came back drawing at 50. Lesnar has been ruined since WM 29 and Cripple H went over for no reason.

 

[Lo-Co]

That's just WWE booking and Cripple H jealousy. Goldberg is one of the biggest stars in history. He came back drawing at 50. Lesnar has been ruined since WM 29 and Cripple H went over for no reason.

I don't disagree with that. I just got into Goldberg late is all. ​

 

[hazardous]

If Lesnar didn't come back I'd have put Goldberg first.

 

[NYChase718]

Goldberg in 03 was book retarded because they didn't bring him in as the machine

He was wrestling regular length matches and opponents making him struggle at times

In wcw he took a few blows but won wit the quickness
Even changed his theme to that bullshyt


They got it right last year

 

[Hey_zeus]

1st run Brock had potential to be one of the best wrestlers of all time. This ain't even close. For the sake of discussion tho:

• Brock
• Tista
• Goldberg

 

[Ill Lou Malnati]

1. Brock
2. Goldberg
3. Batista