Cacs outchea sayin Melo was never a top 5 player at any point in his career...

[Detroit Wave]

 

[Remote]

He probably wasn’t but Hoody Melo was.

#StayMe7o

 

[CouldBeWorse]

Maybe in 2013. Maybe

 

[Detroit Wave]

Maybe in 2013. Maybe

Right that really is the only chance of him being top 5. I personally had him top 5 in 2013

 

[Tate]

He was borderline for a while. In 12-13 probably put him there.

Reddit boys hate melo something serious though. Get some vibes off all that vitriol. But melo kinda easy to hate on tbh

 

[lurker emeritus]

 

[Tony D'Amato]

He was never top 5. Maybe in scoting, but thats it .Hes always been a 1 trick pony.

 

[ItWasWritten]

I disagree here

The year when he went to the western finals and play Kobe he was pretty good , his defense picked up substantially and he was great offensively.

I'd say he was top 5 that year and then in 2013 on the Knicks ...

Also low key, I felt he should have won rookie of the year , dude had his team in the playoffs in the west while Bron was watching him from home in the east

 

[Sterling Archer]

Every season that Melo was in the west, he only lost in the playoffs to the team that either won the NBA title or won the the west (except for once to the clippers). And never lost to a team that he was supposed to beat in the post season.

 

[Columbo]

Cacs are of course mad at the thread title and coming in here to argue

Anyways of course Melo was a top 5 player, he was an unstoppable scorer and very good rebounder. He used to maul and bully nikkas something serious

 

[killacal]

White boys mad he made them drink chocolate milk and they ended up more flabby than him

 

[The Coochie Assassin]

The history books will not be favorable for Melo. He underachieved BIG TIME.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

Every season that Melo was in the west, he only lost in the playoffs to the team that either won the NBA title or won the the west (except for once to the clippers). And never lost to a team that he was supposed to beat in the post season.

This... and NY’s most successful run in the last 20 years was with Melo....

Heyward and Love ain’t never won a series as the man and they make 25/30 mil respectfully but them ofays won’t open they mouth about them unless it’s somethung good

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

The history books will not be favorable for Melo. He underachieved BIG TIME.

He didn’t under achieve... he made a bad career move in going to the knicks.... he lost mostly to championship teams with HOF players and coaches

 

[NY's #1 Draft Pick]

Must be the same CaCs that post in here