Big 12 Quarterbacks and the Heisman trophy...

[CrimsonTider]

As fans of college football is there something we can do about this?

Every year Some QB puts up Arena league numbers in that joke of a conference and gets all kind of heisman consideration.

Colt McCoy
RG3
Klein
Sam Bradford
Jason White
Vince Young.


Am I the only person that has a problem with this?

 

[sm0ke]

Yeah, imagine the numbers McElroy would have put up playing against those defenses.

 

[JBoy]

2 of the last 4 winners have been SEC players though

 

[MikelArteta]

Yeah, imagine the numbers McElroy would have put up playing against those defenses.

He may not be your quarterback but he will be your boss one day

Lundquist laugh

 

[HHR]

...why is this a problem? Are they not having great seasons?

 

[CrimsonTider]

2 of the last 4 winners have been SEC players though

 

[CrimsonTider]

...why is this a problem? Are they not having great seasons?

Big 12 defenses are a joke. They are having great seasons, but playing the big 12 has to be taken into account.

 

[Smooth3d]

Jealousy that the SEC has weak QB's

 

[Smooth3d]

Big 12 defenses are a joke. They are having great seasons, but playing the big 12 has to be taken into account.

Big 12 normally has highly rated defenses second only to the SEC but this year BIG 12 defense do suck save for OU AND K-State.

 

[HHR]

Big 12 defenses are a joke. They are having great seasons, but playing the big 12 has to be taken into account.

Who should be considered then? The abysmal SEC QBs? Pac-10? ACC ?

SOMEONE has to show up to the ceremony

 

[Street Knowledge]

Baylor has one of the worst defensive teams I've ever seen

 

[ECA]

Jealousy that the SEC has weak QB's

SEC QB's have better careers in the pros than Big 12 QB's do.

 

[CrimsonTider]

Who should be considered then? The abysmal SEC QBs? Pac-10? ACC ?

SOMEONE has to show up to the ceremony

The way the teams play in the big12 their top QBs are always going to have better numbers than anyone in the Nation.

Those absymal SEC QBs are playing the best defenses.

 

[CrimsonTider]

Geno Smith was leading the heisman conversation prior to Klein.

Its to the point now, where you are going to have to have a good story for someone other than a big 12 QB win the heisman.

 

[CrimsonTider]

Big 12 normally has highly rated defenses second only to the SEC but this year BIG 12 defense do suck save for OU AND K-State.

Big12 have the worse defenses ever.