Just watched first episode, and I have to say I was pleasantly surprised. I thought it would be wack, but it was pretty decent.
The Good:
-Got a B:TAS vibe from the show - definitely more serious than
Batman: Brave and the Bold or
The Batman
-TV-PG rating means the show probably won't be too heavily censored.
-The voice acting was exceptional, especially Batman and Alfred. Possibly the best Batman voice I've heard outside of Kevin Conroy
-Action sequences were decent
-I'm not a huge fan of CG animated series, but the animation was passable.
-Staying away from
villains like Joker, Penguin, Mr. Freeze, etc. is probably a good thing
The Bad:
-The villains in the first episode (Professor Pym and the Toad Guy) weren't terribly interesting. Their dialogue was kind of funny but their actual actions and motives were pretty boring. Just kidnapping rich people for some petty grudge or something. I don't mind them using lesser known villains but hopefully the next ones are a bit more original.
-The music was pretty meh
Other thoughts:
-Since when did Alfred get that tall and swole (pause)? Dude was looking like a pro wrestler.
-Not too sure about Katana, I'll reserve judgement.
-Batman seems like he got his ass kicked a bit too easily, but that's no big deal. Better than being invincible.
Overall I liked it though, all it needs is a few better villains and I'll be all in. I'd give it a 3.75/5.