Baker Mayfield or Justin Herbert?
- Thread starter the next guy
- Start date
Idk but it’s closer than people will say. Herbert is more physically talented/ better arm.
Baker has a better touch on his throws and eats up zone defenses and puts up big numbers. I really like how Baker has played on the Bucs. I lean towards Herbert tho
Baker has a better touch on his throws and eats up zone defenses and puts up big numbers. I really like how Baker has played on the Bucs. I lean towards Herbert tho
the next guy
Superstar
bump
Faker Gayfield? fukk outta here
VegetasHairline
Veteran
Neither
Look the part vs actual production. The only argument for Herbert is measurables and potential. Baker has put up numbers and won in the playoffs at multiple spots. Tampa wasnt supposed to be shyt after Brady left.
I’ll go with Herbert and pray he get the p*ssy juice out his heart
yseJ
Empire strikes back
Herbert has way more potential...but Baker actually produces
also I know this while Baker is a fukking a$$hole he plays hard and goes all out....teammates play hard for him. he makes some crazy plays and throws his body around like his life depended on it...thats commendable and not sure Herbert is the same kind of emotional leader
with all that said
Baker is at or very close to his ceiling tho, Herbert got most of his career and prime still ahead of him
also I know this while Baker is a fukking a$$hole he plays hard and goes all out....teammates play hard for him. he makes some crazy plays and throws his body around like his life depended on it...thats commendable and not sure Herbert is the same kind of emotional leader
with all that said
Baker is at or very close to his ceiling tho, Herbert got most of his career and prime still ahead of him
for 20 mill less a year and similar production? I'm taking BakeDawg. 
OnlyOneBoss
Superstar
There is no legitimate reason for anyone to pick Herbert other than they don't like Baker/Herby has better PR
Actual Results >>>> Hypotehticals
VegetasHairline
Veteran
Baker Mayfield has a whopping 2 playoff wins and was a number one overall pick.
Two playoff wins, close, competitive games with KC, Detroit last yr, Washington this yr. Herbert's playoff resume is horrible.
Herbert has a strong arm but hasn't produced like Baker.
